Laurie Foster resigned as chair of the Honolulu Police Commission on Wednesday, two days before apologizing for a mislabeled agenda item that left surveillance technology off the public notice.
The item, listed under New Business as a meeting with the ACLU, omitted any reference to drones, real-time crime centers, or automated license plate readers that commissioners had discussed with the civil liberties group, HawaiiNewsNow reported. Foster said she intended only to note that the meeting had occurred, not to open a discussion on future technology acquisitions.
Commissioner Jeannine Souki will serve as acting chair while the commission prepares for a January vote on a permanent replacement, according to Wisevoter. The episode has reignited debate over how Hawaii’s Sunshine Law deadlines intersect with civilian oversight of police surveillance.
“It was just a bad mistake, and you can’t have that,” Foster told HawaiiNewsNow. “You just can’t have that because I don’t want the public to mistrust the police commission.”

The agenda item that triggered the resignation
Agenda item two described a gathering between the ACLU and commissioners Chris Magnus and Jeannine Souki. Foster acknowledged the meeting was a casual meet-and-greet that had already taken place, but the wording gave no indication of the surveillance tools discussed.
“It’s the drones. It’s the real-time crime centers. It’s the license plate readers. It’s all of that is in a package,” Foster said, describing the technology at issue. She said the item should have either been labeled as a past meeting or included the specific technologies so residents could track the conversation.
A tight Sunshine Law filing deadline and an internet outage at the Honolulu Police Department contributed to the oversight, Foster told HawaiiNewsNow. Once public testimony flagged the omission, she concluded the damage to public trust required her departure.
Colleagues praise Foster’s tenure despite the exit
Chief David Lazar called Foster’s leadership “incredible” in a statement released by the department. “I learned a great deal from her, and her guidance and advice have been invaluable to me in my role as Chief of Police,” Lazar said. “Her service as chair has left a lasting impact on the department and the people of Honolulu.”
The commission’s formal statement, reported by KITV, credited Foster with guiding the body through the recruitment and hiring of the new chief during her tenure, which began with her appointment as a commissioner in February 2024.
Acting Chair Jeannine Souki echoed that sentiment. “Laurie has given a tremendous amount of time and energy in service to the Honolulu Police Commission, the Honolulu Police Department and to our community,” Souki said in a statement provided to KITV. “Her leadership and commitment helped guide the Commission through an important period.”

law requires agendas post before meeting
The controversy illustrates a structural tension in Hawaii’s open-meetings framework. The Sunshine Law requires agendas to be posted at least six calendar days before a meeting, a deadline that can compress the time staff have to draft precise descriptions of complex policy items.
When an internet outage at HPD coincides with that window, the risk of vague or incomplete agenda language increases. Foster’s resignation underscores how a single labeling error can undermine the civilian oversight model the commission is designed to protect.
Civil liberties advocates have long argued that surveillance technologies — particularly real-time crime centers that aggregate camera feeds, license plate data, and sensor networks — require specific, searchable agenda entries so the public can participate meaningfully. The ACLU meeting itself signals that the commission was engaging those concerns, but the agenda failed to reflect the substance.
What comes next for the commission
The commission will vote on a permanent chairperson in January. Until then, Souki sets the agenda and presides over meetings that will likely return to the surveillance technology discussion Foster’s item obscured.
Residents who follow police oversight can track that January vote as the next signal of how the body will handle transparency. The agenda controversy shows that how a public meeting item is labeled determines whether residents can find and follow discussions about police technology.
“That’s a real opportunity, to step back and have a vision for this commission and say, ‘What level of oversight do we want for HPD?’” Foster said.