Liberal MP Urges Split Vote on MAID Bill as Second Reading Passes

Liberal MP Marcus Powlowski told reporters the MAID bill should be split so Parliament can vote separately on advance requests and the mental-illness exclusion.

The intervention matters because Bill C-41 bundles two distinct policies — allowing advance requests for people with degenerative conditions like dementia, and permanently blocking the scheduled expansion of eligibility to those whose sole condition is mental illness — into a single legislative vehicle that must clear the Commons and Senate by March 17, 2027, the date the current law would otherwise open MAID to mental illness alone.

“Conservatives are split on the issue,” Powlowski, who chaired the parliamentary committee that studied MAID, said Wednesday. “I think people may have had conflicting views on those two issues.”

Second reading clears with limited debate

The bill passed second reading on November 17 by a vote of 225 to 89 and now moves to the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights. Justice Minister Sean Fraser moved a motion to limit debate at second reading to one additional day, over Opposition objections that the timeline was too compressed for legislation touching on life-and-death consent rules.

Nearly 40 Conservative MPs voted in favor at second reading despite reservations about the advance-request provisions. The Bloc Québécois also criticized the government’s decision to curtail debate on such sensitive legislation.

Liberal MP Urges Split Vote on MAID Bill as Second Reading Passes
Photo: Horizon Weekly

What the bill actually does

Bill C-41 would amend the Criminal Code to permit eligible adults to make advance requests for MAID before losing decision-making capacity — a change aimed at people diagnosed with dementia, ALS, and similar degenerative diseases. Two independent medical or nurse practitioners would have to confirm the request meets legal requirements, and the legislation would prohibit proceeding if the person demonstrates refusal or resistance.

Provinces would decide whether to fulfill advance requests through their health systems and would need to enact their own legislative frameworks and safeguards, according to the government’s media release cited across the Canadian Press wire.

Simultaneously, the bill would prevent the March 2027 expansion of MAID to individuals whose sole underlying condition is a mental illness — a pause the Conservatives support but want decoupled from the advance-request provisions so each can be studied and voted on independently.

Conservative caucus divided on advance requests

Conservative MP Ben Lobb, who voted for the bill at second reading, said he wants more clarity on advance requests and stronger protections for people with mental illnesses.

His colleague Corey Tochor went further: “The expansion of MAID is wrong for our society, and it’s a nuanced position that every Canadian is very sensitive to. I just believe it’s horrendous what we’re doing with MAID in Canada today.”

Liberal MP Urges Split Vote on MAID Bill as Second Reading Passes
Photo: meadowlakeNOW

That split — supporting the mental-illness exclusion while demanding more scrutiny on advance requests — is exactly the dynamic Powlowski highlighted. The Conservatives have urged the government to split the bill; the Liberals have so far kept it intact, arguing the March deadline requires a single legislative vehicle.

The March 2027 deadline

Under current law, the temporary exclusion for mental illness expires on March 17, 2027. Unless Parliament passes legislation extending or making permanent that exclusion, MAID eligibility will automatically expand to include people whose sole condition is a mental disorder. That hard deadline is driving the government’s compressed timeline and its reluctance to divide the bill.

Advance requests, by contrast, represent a new regulatory framework requiring provincial implementation — a complexity that Opposition MPs argue deserves its own debate and vote, not a rushed attachment to a deadline-driven mental-illness provision.

Powlowski, a physician who practised for seven years in Swaziland, The Gambia, Papua New Guinea and Vanuatu before working in Norway House Cree Nation and Thunder Bay’s emergency department, co-chaired the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying that studied the issue. He has lobbied against expanding MAID to cases where mental illness is the sole underlying condition, calling for additional safeguards and a more cautious approach.

Committee studies the bill before the March 2027 deadline

The bill now goes to committee for clause-by-clause study. Whether the government accepts amendments to separate the two measures — or whether the Senate will insist on that division — remains the central unresolved question before the March 2027 deadline.