Loneliness in Vermont: Finding Community From Gardens to Neighborhood Bars

In a column for Vermont Public, Josh Crane explores how Vermonters find and keep community amid what poll data shows is a growing sense of isolation across the state.

The question came from Ash Hoyt, a 33-year-old Burlington resident who told Vermont Public that her hardest stretch of loneliness hit during her first winter living alone in Vermont roughly eight years ago.

“It was a lot of: Go to work, come home, and then it was like, ‘OK, now what?'” Hoyt said. “And then it was, like, from 5:00 to 10:00 you’re alone, and I think that experiencing winter and the darkness felt really grim and never-ending.”

A recent Vermont Public poll surveyed hundreds of residents on the issue. More than half of respondents said they had “just a few” nearby friends or relatives — or none at all — they could rely on for help or support. That figure is up almost 10 percentage points from a similar poll conducted in 2019.

The gap between acquaintances and reliance

Respondents who spoke to Vermont Public described a sharp distinction between knowing people and having people to call in a crisis. “I have a large community of people that I know, but that’s really different than people that you can rely on,” Cristine told the outlet. Jack added: “I have many acquaintances. I have very few friends.”

Marylynn, another respondent, noted the compounding effect of age: “And the older you get, the less friends you have because they’re all dying too.” Philip described activity-based connections that don’t extend beyond the shared pursuit: “When I go skiing, I see friends that I ski with. Also, the same as people that I go hiking with. We don’t seem to make connections beyond that activity.”

Even offers of practical help can feel transactional rather than relational. “I’m sure if, you know, I put something out on Front Porch Forum of, ‘Hey, I need help moving wood,’ or something, people would respond to that,” Jack said. “But they’re there because they’re good people. They’re not necessarily there because of me.”

Churches provide community networks for some

For some, institutions fill the gap. Erika told Vermont Public that joining a church gave her an instant network of mutual aid. “When I did, I joined a church, and through that church you instantly, at least it feels instantly, that you have a group of people who will be with you through thick and thin,” she said.

“My only experience of that has ever been through a church.” She contrasted it with other places she has lived: “I never had that kind of community connection.”

But the “outsider” dynamic remains a barrier for newcomers. Bryan, who moved to Vermont from elsewhere, said he loves the area and the people he meets, but feels a ceiling on intimacy. “There is a definite sense of outsider,” he said. “It can only go so far.”

Low-stakes spaces: gardens and bars

Hoyt has built her own web of connection over years. She tends a plot at the Archibald Community Garden in Burlington’s Old North End, runs a pop-up nail salon in a nearby park to bring people together, and helps college students connect with neighbors through her job at UVM.

The garden, she said, serves as a low-stakes refuge. “This is also a place that feels low stakes when I’m feeling lonely,” Hoyt told Vermont Public. “Before you got here, there was someone here that I know — I don’t know her other than the fact that she also has a plot here.”

Crane took that idea — that community doesn’t always require deep friendship — to the Olde Northender, a neighborhood bar in the same Old North End. He arrived around 6:30 p.m. on a wintry Monday to find a mix of laborers and technology workers watching Jeopardy! together.

“It’s a working class bar. There’s a lot of labor employees here and there’s also a lot of technology people that are here as well,” patron Chris said. “It’s a vibrant mix, I think.”

The bar is unpretentious. A bumper sticker on the door reads “Start your bender at the Olde Northender.” Across the street sits China Express 2; patrons bring takeout in to eat at the bar. Behind the counter, a Cool Whip container holds a plant, and a sign reads “Sorry, we’re open.” The bar opens daily at 8 a.m.

Longtime bartender Tommy Dubuc, 63, grew up in Shelburne and South Burlington and started at the Northender in 2013 after more than two decades at an Irish pub popular with UVM students.

“Time to get out of the college bars. My kids were college students. I didn’t wanna be near them … no,” he told Vermont Public. He refers to himself as the “bar dad” and keeps a stash of chocolate behind the bar for anyone having an especially bad day.

Loneliness as a shared, not solitary, experience

Back at the garden, Hoyt and Crane discussed the texture of loneliness itself. “It feels low, but it also feels so high,” Hoyt said.

“It’s like the perfect combo of feeling really low and also, like, anxious about it. Um, like, ‘What’s wrong with me? Is this ever gonna end?'” Crane described the paradox of feeling loneliest in a crowd: “Sometimes when I’m in more social settings, I will feel more, like, inside my own head. And therefore I’ll feel lonelier.”

Both described comfort in chosen solitude — sitting at a bar alone, dining solo — where the pressure to perform drops away. “Being alone, like, being comfortable being alone with yourself, people struggle with that forever,” Hoyt said. “I’ll go out to dinner by myself, like, you can leave when you wanna leave, like sit at the bar, chat with the bartender.”

Jack, the poll respondent, framed the stigma bluntly: “Loneliness in general seems to be treated as a personal failing. If you’re lonely, it’s your own fault. You haven’t gone out and met people, you know? You haven’t, uh, haven’t made enough of an effort. You haven’t changed yourself.”

Philip admitted a similar internalization: “I’ve gotten pretty lazy about it, uh, more recently, and I think about how I should work harder to make, uh, more friends.”

Cristine, whose illness narrowed her world, described the loss of reciprocal friendships. “Before my illness worsened, I did not feel lonely. I had so many people and so many things to do, and I had so much energy, and now that I can’t do that, yeah, there’s a lot of loneliness,” she said.

“So many of the people who you know, swore that we were friends and that we would, you know, help each other did not show up.”

What she misses most is the freedom to be unguarded: “When I think about, like, what would make me feel less lonely, like, having the friends who really get me where I do not need to mask one single bit, like that is, that’s so freeing. I wish everybody had that.”

Vermont Public, the statewide broadcaster that commissioned the poll and published the column, was formed in 2021 by the merger of Vermont Public Radio, founded in 1977, and Vermont Public Television, whose roots trace to Vermont Educational Television in 1967. The combined organization became the state’s largest newsroom, uniting 57 radio and 42 television employees with $90 million in assets.

Hoyt offered a reframing: “Loneliness feels like a taboo topic sometimes. It’s like, if you say you are lonely you’re, like, you’re scaring other people or, like, unworthy. But to be human is to be lonely.”