The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled Monday that a noncompete agreement signed by a parent company — but not the subsidiary that actually employs the worker — fails the state’s signature requirement and is unenforceable.
The decision in Anaplan Parent, LP and Anaplan, Inc. v. Timothy Brennan affirms a Superior Court denial of injunctive relief and draws a bright line for employers using equity awards to bind subsidiary employees: the entity that pays the salary must sign the restrictive covenant.
Writing for the court, Justice Scott Kafker concluded that a parent company is not the “employer” of a subsidiary’s employee under the Massachusetts Noncompetition Agreement Act (MNAA) simply because it holds equity or exercises corporate oversight. The ruling rejects arguments that joint-venture principles or third-party beneficiary clauses can cure the missing signature.
“Having taken advantage of the benefits of this separateness, they may not disavow that form when it is to their advantage.”
the court wrote, dismissing the parent’s attempt to enforce the agreement through corporate structure it otherwise treats as distinct.
Brennan Received Parent Company Interests
Timothy Brennan worked for Anaplan, Inc., a subsidiary of Anaplan Parent, LP. Over three equity incentive agreements, Brennan received limited partnership interests in the parent company in exchange for restrictive covenants, including a noncompete. The parent signed each agreement and named the subsidiary as a third-party beneficiary. The subsidiary never signed.

When Brennan left in 2025 to join a competitor, both entities sued and sought a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction. The Superior Court denied the motion on the noncompete claim, finding the MNAA’s signature requirement unmet. The SJC heard oral argument in September and issued its decision Monday.
“Employer” Means the Entity Receiving the Services
The MNAA requires a noncompete to be “in writing and signed by both the employer and employee.” The statute does not define “employer,” but defines “employee” to include individuals performing services for an entity under the state’s independent contractor law (M.G.L. c. 149, § 148B).
The SJC reasoned that an employer is, at minimum, the entity for which the individual performs services. Brennan performed services solely for the subsidiary. The parent did not hire, supervise, pay, or fire him, nor maintain his employment records. The parent did not argue it was a joint employer.
The court also rejected the parent’s invocation of joint-venture liability, finding no evidence the parent and subsidiary entered a joint venture as to Brennan. They maintained separate corporate forms and could not collapse that distinction selectively.
MNAA Applies Even When Employer Fails to Sign
The companies argued alternatively that if the parent was not the employer, the MNAA did not apply at all because the agreement fell “outside of an employment relationship.” The SJC disagreed.
The court examined the agreements’ terms: they acknowledged Brennan entered the covenants “in connection with his employment with” the subsidiary; the noncompete was designed to prevent competition with the subsidiary after that employment ended; the subsidiary was named a third-party beneficiary; and consideration — equity in the parent — was exchanged for the promise not to compete with the subsidiary.
Because the restriction was tethered to Brennan’s employment with his actual employer, it fell squarely within the MNAA’s definition of a noncompetition agreement “between an employer and an employee” or “otherwise arising out of an … employment relationship.”
Practical Fallout for Employers
The ruling forces a straightforward compliance check: any noncompete subject to the MNAA covering a Massachusetts employee must be signed by the employing entity. Parent-level equity award agreements that omit the subsidiary’s signature are invalid.
If an employer seeks to cure a defective agreement with a new one, the replacement must satisfy the MNAA’s requirements for mid-employment noncompetes: fair and reasonable consideration independent of continued employment, and at least 10 business days’ notice before the agreement takes effect.
Employers should also evaluate alternatives that sit outside the MNAA’s scope — non-solicitation of customers or employees, and confidentiality agreements — which remain enforceable tools for protecting trade secrets and client goodwill.
Companies Should Audit Existing Equity and Incentive Plans
The decision is final. Anaplan Parent and Anaplan, Inc. have no further appeal within the state system. Companies with Massachusetts workforces should audit existing equity and incentive plans immediately to confirm the employing entity is a signatory on every restrictive covenant.