Mayor Zohran Mamdani acknowledged Friday that New York City will miss its legal deadline to close Rikers Island by five years, proposing a new shutdown date of 2032 while the jail population sits 2,100 people above the capacity of the four replacement jails still under construction.
The plan, detailed in a city report released Friday, acknowledges what officials have avoided saying aloud: the August 2027 deadline set by the City Council in 2019 is unattainable. Construction on the borough-based facilities is behind schedule, and the detained population has risen to roughly 6,600 as of early November — well above the 4,500 beds the four new jails will provide.
“It is time to finally close Rikers Island,” Mamdani said in a statement.
“For decades, New Yorkers have demanded a correctional system that is safe and humane. This plan puts us on a path to deliver just that: closing Rikers, reducing pretrial detention, tackling the case delays that deprive people of their right to a speedy trial and investing $146m in the evidence-based supports that helps break the cycles of incarceration.”
The proposal kicks off what will be a contentious negotiation with the City Council, which must pass new legislation to extend the legal deadline. Speaker Julie Menin signaled openness to the delay, saying “delays under previous administrations have made it clear that more time is needed to fulfill the commitment the City Council made to New Yorkers in 2019.”

A population mismatch no construction schedule can solve
The central obstacle is arithmetic, not architecture. The borough-based jails — slated for Brooklyn, the Bronx, Queens and Manhattan — are designed for a combined 4,500 beds. Yet the city holds about 6,600 people today, and about 5,600 of them are awaiting trial, according to figures cited by Political.org. The administration’s own targets require shrinking that population to 5,500 by the time the Brooklyn facility opens in 2029, and to 4,100 by the final 2032 closure.
That reduction hinges on moving cases faster. The average length of stay in city jails rose to 116 days in fiscal year 2026, up from 87 days the prior year, the city’s report shows. Meanwhile, 56 percent fewer people were sent to Rikers pretrial in 2025 than in 2017, yet the total jail population dropped only 22 percent over the same span — evidence that people are simply languishing longer behind bars.
“The report identifies prolonged detention as a major driver of the jail population,” the Political.org analysis noted. “The plan argues the population has not grown because of more arrests. It says people are waiting longer for their cases to resolve.”
Courts, not cops, hold the key
To accelerate case processing, Mamdani will create a Case Delay Task Force bringing together the Office of Court Administration, district attorneys and the defense bar. The city does not control court calendars — the state does — making judicial cooperation the single biggest variable in whether the 2032 target holds.
The plan also promises $290 million through fiscal year 2030 for population-reduction efforts, including $146 million next fiscal year for mental health care, substance-use treatment, educational and vocational programming, and victim services. Another $76 million would expand reentry services and community diversion programs such as supportive housing, while $16 million would fund services for crime victims and survivors.
An additional $50 million would expand vocational training, educational programming, mental health counseling and substance-use services inside the jails, according to the city’s news release.
Federal oversight complicates the handoff
Rikers is currently under the authority of a federal court-appointed remediation manager, installed in January after a judge found “abnormal and unacceptable” conditions under former Mayor Eric Adams. Nine people have died in city jail custody so far this year, Political.org noted. Mamdani’s administration said it would work with the federal monitor, the Board of Correction and the City Council to “bring this plan into law.”
The plan also pledges to replace the island’s 2,450 defective doors, improve sanitary conditions and “reimagine” staff training — an acknowledgment that conditions must improve during the extended timeline.
From jail complex to climate infrastructure
The report spends considerable space on the island's future reuse, examining "near-term renewable energy and sustainability projects" for the 400-acre site once it empties. The North Infirmary Command, a 1932 facility described as a “vacant jail,” was closed in June and transferred to the Department of Citywide Administrative Services, along with large portions of two other centers.
Construction costs for the four borough jails have ballooned from an original $8.7 billion estimate to $15.5 billion, according to the Independent Rikers Commission, a figure cited by Political.org. The city has committed to quarterly public updates on progress.
“We have a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers,” Mamdani said. “Working alongside the City Council, Courts and nonprofit partners, we will meet it — for the people in our custody, the staff who serve them, victims of crime, and every New Yorker.”
The City Council must now decide whether to codify a five-year extension that pushes the legal deadline past three mayoral administrations since the original 2019 vote.
Keep reading