Mayor Mamdani Signs Horse-Carriage Ban; TWU Sues Over Law

Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed the horse-carriage ban into law Thursday, and the Transport Workers Union filed a federal lawsuit minutes later.

The ceremony in City Hall’s Blue Room ended a decades-long fight to remove horses from Central Park, but the ink was barely dry before TWU Local 100 — representing roughly 200 drivers and stable hands — asked a Manhattan federal judge to strike the measure down.

The union argues the law seizes medallions purchased for up to $400,000 each without guaranteeing compensation, a taking they say violates the Constitution. New York Daily News reported the suit was filed in the Southern District of New York the same morning.

Named for Romanch Mahajan, the 18-year-old tourist killed in July when a spooked horse bolted and threw his mother from a carriage, Romanch’s Law halts new licenses immediately and sets a June 2028 sunset for the industry.

It also bars owners from selling their horses into carriage work anywhere else. The City Council passed the bill last month with a veto-proof majority. Former Mayor Bill de Blasio, whose own attempts to ban the trade failed, stood beside Mamdani at the signing, alongside Mahajan’s aunt, Sovia Thukral.

“Our city has changed. And now it is time for our laws to change too.”

Mamdani said from the lectern Thursday.

Mayor Mamdani Signs Horse-Carriage Ban; TWU Sues Over Law
Photo: thedailynewsonline.com

The property-rights collision

The legal fight centers on the 68 medallions the city issued — assets the union says are now worthless. Attorney Arthur Schwartz, representing TWU, told reporters outside the courthouse that the city cannot simply zero out property value and promise a buyback later.

“You don’t say, ‘we’re going to take your property, we’ll figure out how to deal with it later,’” Schwartz said. “You can’t do that, that’s not how our constitution works.”

The complaint argues the law unfairly targets Central Park carriage tours while leaving horseback riding, racing, and NYPD mounted units untouched. It also cites stray electrical voltage in the park — first reported by New York Daily News — as a possible cause of the horse spooking that killed Mahajan, suggesting the hazard remains unaddressed for other animals and pedestrians.

Mamdani signs law banning horse-drawn carriages by 2028 #shorts — New York Post

What the transition plan promises

Mamdani indicated earlier this week he would push for a city-funded buyback of the medallions and a job-training program run through CUNY’s LaGuardia Community College. The legislation requires the administration and Council to deliver a transition plan by April.

But TWU International President John Samuelsen called the legislation an “unconstitutional abomination” because those protections were not written into the law itself. “Despite the good intentions of the mayor, the protections he outlined recently should have been written into the legislation,” Samuelsen said in a statement Thursday.

At a press conference outside the courthouse, TWU Local 100 Executive Vice President Alexander Kemp framed the moment in labor terms.

“At 10:00 this morning, we watched the mayor sign into law, and have a round of applause from the City Council, spiking the ball on the heads of 300 workers who no longer have a future in New York City,” Kemp told reporters. “I never imagined a world where people who champion labor would take such pride in eliminating it from Central Park.”

The e-bike counterpoint

The union’s filing draws a sharp contrast: between 2019 and May 2026, the city recorded 17,434 e-bike injuries and 113 deaths, yet the administration has not moved to ban them. Samuelsen argued lawmakers targeted a regulated, unionized industry over “tragic, one-off incidents” while letting “dangerous e-bikers to freely terrorize New Yorkers.”

Horse carriages union mamdani comp
Photo: nypost.com

Animal-rights groups claim victory

For advocates, Thursday closed a 160-year loop. “One hundred and sixty years ago, the mistreatment of a carriage horse inspired Henry Bergh to found the ASPCA, and protecting horses has been central to our mission ever since,” ASPCA President Matt Bershadker said in a statement. “Today’s signing of Romanch’s Law brings that commitment full circle.”

The first court conference in the Southern District of New York has not yet been scheduled.