Montana Senate to Launch Ethics Investigation Into Sen. Jonathan Windy Boy Over Misconduct Allegations

Montana Senate leaders will open a formal ethics investigation into Sen. Jonathan Windy Boy, D-Box Elder, when the Legislature convenes in January, the first official step toward possible discipline or expulsion over allegations of sexual misconduct involving a minor and a former legislative staffer.

Senate President Matt Regier, R-Kalispell, and incoming Senate Minority Leader Laura Smith, D-Helena, announced the referral Wednesday after leadership elections. Both caucuses also agreed to keep Windy Boy off all committee assignments for the 2027 session while the inquiry proceeds, a move that effectively sidelines the chamber’s longest-serving member.

Bipartisan referral, stripped assignments

Regier and Smith each framed the decision as a matter of due process and accountability. “Obviously due process, but there needs to be justice and accountability held there for the senator,” Regier said. Smith, a former prosecutor, added, “I think everyone in our caucus recognizes the seriousness of the allegations.”

The allegations surfaced earlier this year during Windy Boy’s brief run for Montana’s eastern U.S. House seat. They include claims he sent sexually inappropriate messages to a minor and showed an explicit photo of himself to a former legislative staffer.

Windy Boy dropped out of the race citing health reasons, then re-entered it, calling the accusations “a coordinated political smear” and noting he has never been criminally charged.

Jonathan Windy Boy
Photo: krtv.com

Forty senators demanded resignation

In May, 40 of the Senate’s 50 members — spanning both parties — signed a letter urging Windy Boy to resign. He declined. The Ethics Committee named Wednesday consists of Sen. Forrest Mandeville, R-Columbus, and Sen. Christopher Pope, D-Bozeman, who chaired and vice-chaired the panel last session, plus newly elected Sens. Amy Regier, R-Kalispell, and Erin Farris-Olsen, D-Helena. None of the four signed the resignation letter.

If the committee recommends action, a two-thirds vote of the full Senate would be required to punish or expel Windy Boy. “He is a person who was elected by his community and sits in that seat,” Smith said. “If an ethics proceeding happens and something else occurs and the body decides that’s not the case, then we’ll deal with that when it happens.”

New rules aim to speed the process

Regier said leadership has proposed new ethics procedures for the coming session, which joint rules committees will review in the coming weeks. “We didn’t have that framework last session,” he said.

“So it’ll depend what Joint Rules does with it, but I thought it was a fairly good ethics process, so that I’m assuming will make things smoother — I don’t know if it’ll make it faster.”

Democratic Party renews call to step down

The Montana Democratic Party issued a statement Wednesday backing the investigation and the committee-stripping decision. “People who report sexual misconduct deserve to be heard and to know they can speak up without fear of retaliation,” party chair Bruce Knutson said.

“The allegations against Sen. Windy Boy, some involving minors and former legislative employees, are grave. We called on him to resign in April. We’re asking him again today to step down.”

Windy Boy, who has served in the Legislature since 2003, was at the Capitol last week for orientation. MTN reached out to him Wednesday but did not receive an immediate response.