Nationwide Sues US Over ICE Agent’s Red-Light Crash in Providence

“They ended up going through the red light with their lights on. No siren. Just like only, and then I just saw this white car smack him,” a witness told Providence police, body-camera footage shows.

Nationwide Insurance and its policyholder Stacy Lacapra have now sued the United States in federal court in Rhode Island, alleging an ICE agent ran a red light without a siren and collided with her BMW.

The three-page complaint, filed this week in U.S. District Court, names Adam Crawford as the driver of a Department of Homeland Security-owned 2021 Ford Expedition that collided with Lacapra’s white 2017 BMW 330i at Chalkstone and Oakland avenues on Oct. 14, 2025, Go Local Prov reported. The suit seeks $21,586.64 — $19,586.64 in vehicle damages Nationwide has already paid plus $2,000 in medical benefits, according to the filing and NBC 10 reporting.

Vicarious liability under the Federal Tort Claims Act is the legal engine here: the government answers for employees acting within the scope of their duties. The plaintiffs argue Crawford breached his duty of care by entering the intersection against a red signal without activating his siren, violating Rhode Island General Law § 31-12-6, which governs emergency-vehicle operation. Attorney Corey Mastin represents Nationwide and Lacapra.

Nationwide Sues US Over ICE Agent's Red-Light Crash in Providence
Photo: coastalabc.com

Providence police reports add texture the complaint does not. Witnesses said the unmarked Expedition had its emergency lights illuminated but no siren sounding when it entered the intersection, NBC 10 reported. A second driver, identified by police as a Providence College student, said masked agents converged on the scene and told him to “settle down,” adding, “He just T-boned me.”

NBC 10 has requested comment from ICE and had not received a response as of Wednesday. The agency has not filed a court response yet; the docket shows only the initial complaint. A scheduling conference will set the litigation calendar in the coming weeks.

Insurance company sues U.S. government over crash involving ICE agent — NBC 10 WJAR

“Defendant is vicariously liable for Adam Crawford’s negligent operation and failure to comply with R.I.G.L. § 31-12-6,” the complaint says.

The case turns on whether Crawford’s use of lights without a siren satisfies the state statute’s requirements for emergency-vehicle exemptions. Rhode Island law requires both audible and visual signals when an emergency vehicle proceeds past a red light.

For Lacapra and Nationwide, the stake is about $21,586.64 — roughly the cost of a mid-size sedan repair — but the precedent matters. The next docket entry will be the government’s answer or a motion to dismiss.