New Jersey Sues DHS Over Delaney Hall Subpoena Stonewalling

“There are far too many reports of inhumane treatment of the people held at Delaney Hall. But what we have received for months from both GEO Group and DHS is plain stonewalling,” Attorney General Jennifer Davenport said Tuesday.

New Jersey sued the U.S. Department of Homeland Security in federal court asking a judge to force the agency to respond to a subpoena the state issued in August. The subpoena seeks records on medical care, staff qualifications, infectious-disease protocols and use-of-force incidents at Delaney Hall, the 1,196-bed immigration detention center in Newark operated by the private contractor GEO Group.

The legal fight has been building since early August, when Davenport’s Division on Civil Rights opened an investigation under the New Jersey Civil Rights Act and the Law Against Discrimination after at least three detainees died in custody.

GEO Group declined to comply with the subpoena on Aug. 21, the day it was due, saying federal rules required ICE approval before the company could release records from its work for the agency. A GEO lawyer wrote on Sept. 3 that requests for records about detention or medical care “necessitate review and approval by ICE.”

NJ sues DHS over Delaney Hall investigation — CBS New York

State lawyers argue that GEO Group, as a private business operating on its own property, can comply with a state subpoena without federal permission. Even if federal rules cover some records, the state contends the company should still produce medical staff training manuals and confirm whether its health-care providers hold New Jersey licenses.

New Jersey sent DHS a copy of the subpoena on Sept. 29 with an Oct. 7 deadline. Investigators followed up on Oct. 20, citing evidence from witness statements, medical records and other documents, and asked for a decision by Nov. 5. Neither letter received a reply.

New Jersey Sues DHS Over Delaney Hall Subpoena Stonewalling
Photo: newjerseymonitor.com

“These repeated inquiries have been met with silence.”

state lawyers wrote in the complaint

The complaint alleges that the delay violates the federal Administrative Procedure Act. It also details what investigators say they have uncovered so far: detainees going without medication for chronic conditions, staff failing to respond adequately to medical emergencies, excessive force by guards, sexual assault, lack of disability accommodations and routine denial of language interpretation — including during medical screenings and when detainees were asked to sign forms for their immigration cases.

An ICE inspection in September identified 22 deficiencies under federal detention standards, according to the complaint. Those included problems with medical and mental-health screenings for new arrivals, access to prescription medication, and procedures for preventing and responding to sexual abuse.

AG Davenport Sues DHS For Failing to Respond to Subpoena in Delaney Hall Civil Rights Investigation — New Jersey OAG

Yolanda N. Melville, director of the Division on Civil Rights, said in a statement

ICE did not publicly disclose his death before U.S. Rep. Rob Menendez made it public in August. A third man, Edwin Jovanny Lopez-Cornejo, died Aug. 1.

'Inhumane conditions' at Delaney Hall prompts NJ lawsuit — Eyewitness News ABC7NY

Homeland Security officials have repeatedly said that detainees receive proper medical care. It did not address the state’s subpoena.

It asks the court to declare DHS in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act for unreasonable delay and to set a firm deadline for the agency to communicate its decision.

A separate lawsuit over access to Delaney Hall remains pending.

The complaint is available on the New Jersey Office of the Attorney General website.