New Owners to Take Over The Cookie Jar Eatery Dec. 1 as Kochs Retire After 24 Years

Shelly Gaddis and Michelle Groeneveld will take over The Cookie Jar Eatery on Dec. 1, ending Glen and Elaine Koch’s run at the downtown Sioux Falls staple, SiouxFalls.Business reported Friday.

The Kochs, who celebrated their 50th wedding anniversary this month, plan to retire by year’s end after listing the restaurant for sale several times since 2022. Business broker Stephanie Oulette of KW Commercial said the timing finally aligned. “It’s perfect timing,” Oulette said. “I’m just so happy for them.”

The deal came together after Gaddis, who owned the children’s store Elegant Mommy for 11 years and now teaches entrepreneurship at the University of Sioux Falls, approached Groeneveld with what her friend called a “wild idea.” Groeneveld, leaving a church secretary role, said the shared faith and history between the two women made the decision immediate.

“When she called with a wild idea about taking over The Cookie Jar business, she had so many ideas for it, and I thought, oh, my gosh, I’m totally in on this,” Groeneveld told SiouxFalls.Business.

Gaddis will manage front-of-house operations while Groeneveld oversees the kitchen, learning directly from Elaine Koch during a month-long transition in December. “We’re grateful they’ve chosen us as the people to carry on,” Gaddis said.

The Cookie Jar’s lineage stretches back to at least 1974 in the Western Mall, later moving to the Empire Mall before settling at 10th Street downtown. The Kochs purchased it on July 1, 2002, when the menu was exclusively cookies.

Within six months, customer demand pushed them into lunch service — sloppy joes the first week of every month became a downtown ritual, and faxed menus to area businesses gave way to weekly social media posts.

The Kochs weathered the 2008 financial crisis, the COVID-19 pandemic, and what Elaine Koch described as market saturation in a downtown now dense with dining options. Yet the restaurant, now in the Lumber Exchange building at 101 S. Reid St., retained a loyal base.

“We have people that come in and say, ‘We came to The Cookie Jar when it was in the mall,’ and it makes you feel good it’s been around so long,” Glen Koch said.

Look to the cookie elaine

The new owners plan to keep the scratch-made philosophy — “just like Grandma did,” Gaddis said — and honor existing catering and corporate accounts. They are also weighing Saturday hours, expanding beyond the current weekday breakfast and lunch schedule. The location across from the 8th & Railroad Center, Gaddis noted, remains a natural gathering spot for soup, a sandwich, a Bible study, or a quiet read by the fireplace.

For the Kochs, retirement hasn’t fully settled in. “It will mean we don’t have to wait until the weekend to go camping,” Glen Koch said. Elaine Koch added, “Probably Jan. 1 it’s going to kick in.”