Nvidia Shares Fall After Earnings Beat as Leadership Vacuum Looms

“I mean, Jensen has been probably the most prominent CEO over the last couple of years. Or, you know, in the top couple,” Reddit co-founder and CEO Steve Huffman said at Yahoo Finance Invest.

“Or, you know, in the top couple.” “So I don’t know what this change portends.” “It’s just, it’s change,” said Steve Huffman, co-founder and CEO of Reddit.

Nvidia shares reversed sharply on Wednesday from an initial positive post-earnings reaction after reporting third-quarter earnings that beat Wall Street estimates, leaving the stock down about 3.5% at the time of this writing. The chipmaker posted adjusted earnings of $2.68 a share on revenue of $115.8 billion, topping forecasts of $2.47 a share on $109.15 billion, and guided fourth-quarter revenue of $127.4 billion to $132.6 billion, comfortably above the $125.25 billion analysts were looking for.

Leadership Vacuum Overshadows Beat

Oppenheimer analyst Rich Schafer removed his price target days before the report, calling Huang a “singular leader who leaves impossible shoes to fill.” Interim CEO Colette Kress and new chair Harvey Jones appeared on the earnings call, but Jones’s messaging on the CEO search timeline lacked the urgency the market wanted, according to Yahoo Finance.

Nvidia Shares Fall After Earnings Beat as Leadership Vacuum Looms
Photo: Yahoo Finance

Seaport Research Partners analyst Jay Goldberg questioned whether any internal candidate can run the entire company. “Jensen famously built the structure of the company around himself. Like he’s the center of the wheel and all the things connect to him. And I don’t think anyone internally has as complete a view of the company as Jensen does,” Goldberg said on Yahoo Finance’s Sozzi Unleashed.

Credit Guarantees Link Rivals’ Fate to Nvidia

Nvidia’s financial guarantees — roughly $230 billion in commitments backing data-center builders — have become a transmission belt for sector-wide anxiety. Reuters puts the figure at $230 billion, including up to $105 billion behind the Ohio data center OpenAI plans to lease. When Nvidia shares fell 13% in the week of Huang’s resignation, AMD and Broadcom initially rallied 32% and 18% respectively, only to reverse course and fall alongside Nvidia by Monday.

FXStreet reported that AMD lost 8.75% on November 13 and another 5.6% on Monday, while Nvidia dropped 4.1% the same day. JPMorgan credit analyst Erica Spear said she doesn’t expect existing commitments to change, but new deals could take longer or cost more. Lenders were asking close to 15% a year to hold CoreWeave bonds in the week to November 13, a gauge of what unbacked money costs.

Analysts Split on Valuation Floor

UBS cut its price target to $240 from $300 — still 54% above the November 16 close — while Bank of America lowered its target to $280 from $350, a 79% premium. RBC reduced its target to $230 from $330 (47% upside) and Barclays to $210 from $275 (34% upside). Mizuho kept a $220 target (41% upside), while HSBC downgraded to Hold. Bernstein and Baird also downgraded, with targets at $200 implying 28% and 28% upside respectively.

Nvidia Shares Fall After Earnings Beat as Leadership Vacuum Looms
Photo: Yahoo Finance

Bank of America analyst Vivek Arya noted Nvidia’s 11x forward P/E sits at a multi-decade low, a roughly 36% discount to Broadcom, “reflecting considerable pressure but also enormous rebound potential.” His model shows even flat sales around $700 billion could push 2028 earnings per share above $15, up about 50% from current levels.

Short Sellers Cash in as Retail Buys the Dip

S3 Partners data shows short positions rose to 1.22% of outstanding shares, a nominal $46 billion, generating roughly $24 billion in paper profits over 40 days as the stock fell 35% from its October 6 high. Meanwhile, Vanda Research tracked $2 billion in net retail buying last week, a record single-week volume. Michael Burry, who held December call options as a hedge against short positions, has reduced portfolio risk and increased cash holdings since mid-September.

Broader Market Signals Caution

The S&P 500 closed at the bottom of its June range, and the Nasdaq 100 remained within its decline bounds despite Nvidia’s after-hours pop. tastylive noted the stock selloff began in early October, well before the Huang scandal, and pointed to slowing U.S. retail sales — motor vehicle dealers down 1.6%, furniture down 2.25% in October — as a deeper concern. Fed rate-hike expectations for 2027 have faded as growth worries replace inflation fears.

Sam Altman, CEO of OpenAI, said on November 16 he believes the AI industry can survive the uncertainty caused by Huang’s resignation. Nvidia’s board is reportedly focused on investigations and has not launched consultations on reinstatement, according to 36Kr.

Nvidia Shares Fall After Earnings Beat as Leadership Vacuum Looms
Photo: CNBC