Raising a family in New York City demands nearly $147,000 a year in rent and childcare costs alone, according to a study.
Personal loan experts at Achieve examined family life across 50 US cities by tracking three main expenses: a three-bedroom apartment in the city center, average childcare costs, and a basic basket of groceries. Each city received an affordability score out of 40, with higher numbers marking more affordable locations.
New York City landed at the bottom of the list with a score of 8.6 out of 40. Families squeezing into a three-bedroom apartment in the city center face a monthly rent of $8,856, while childcare adds another $3,365 each month.
Oakland, California, secured second place on the least-affordable ranking with an affordability score of 14.65. Families there encounter monthly rents averaging $4,312 alongside childcare bills of $2,726.

Miami followed in third place with a score of 16.05, where a three-bedroom rental costs $6,060 a month and childcare runs $1,801.46. Boston took fourth place with a score of 16.56, featuring average monthly rent of $5,918 and childcare expenses of $2,900.09.
Washington, DC, claimed fifth place with a score of 17.97. Los Angeles landed in sixth place with an affordability score of 18.24, driven by monthly rent of $5,496.99 and childcare costs of $1,676.09.
Seattle ranked seventh with a score of 18.39, where parents pay $4,784.62 in monthly rent and a staggering $3,012 for childcare. Denver, Colorado, took eighth place with a score of 19.49, Portland, Oregon, placed ninth at 19.26, and Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, rounded out the top 10 at 19.66.
On the opposite end of the spectrum, El Paso, Texas, emerged as the most affordable city in the study with a score of 30 out of 40, boasting average rent of $1,708 and childcare costs of $574.50. Tucson, Arizona, followed in second place with a score of 27.89, where rent averaged $2,122.26 and childcare cost $1,100. Omaha, Nebraska, secured third place at 27.15, Austin, Texas, took fourth at 26.74, and Louisville, Kentucky, placed fifth with a score of 26.58.