Ohio State Defense Surrenders 31 Points to Nebraska, Ending Playoff Hopes

Ohio State’s defense surrendered 31 points to a Nebraska team that had not scored more than 17 against a winning opponent all season, leaving the Buckeyes’ playoff hopes effectively over.

Saturday’s loss marked the fourth of the season for Ohio State, and the defense was the common denominator in each defeat, Eleven Warriors reported. The Buckeyes blew a 20-point fourth-quarter lead against Texas, allowed 70- and 69-yard plays in a 30-point loss at USC, and gave up 41 points to Oregon — the most since 2022.

Ohio State’s defense forced only two punts — on Nebraska’s opening drive of each half — with zero takeaways, and allowed Anthony Colandrea to run for 63 yards on 11 attempts, including a 13-yard touchdown run and a pair of third-down conversions to ice the game on the final possession.

“We're not going to win many games if we give up 31 points and only get two stops in the whole game,” Ryan Day said.

Defensive Scheme Change Fails Against Nebraska

Patricia reverted to a three-down, odd-front alignment against Nebraska after a four-down front produced five sacks against Northwestern the week prior. The pass rush managed one sack and seven total quarterback pressures, per Pro Football Focus. Defensive linemen said all week the plan was to contain quarterback Anthony Colandrea as a runner; he gained 63 yards on 11 carries, including a 13-yard touchdown and two third-down conversions on the game-sealing drive.

The drop-off coincides with a talent drain. Last year’s unit featured four All-Americans — Caleb Downs, Arvell Reese, Sonny Styles and Kayden McDonald — plus Davison Igbinosun and Caden Curry. None were adequately replaced. True freshman Jay Timmons is arguably the best defender on the current roster. The Buckeyes have 17 sacks in 11 games; Kenyatta Jackson leads the team with three.

Buyout Cost Complicates Patricia Evaluation

Moving on from Patricia after one year of a three-year extension averaging $3.8 million annually would cost Ohio State $7.7 million in remaining salary, though the buyout is mitigated by any future earnings, Eleven Warriors reported. Ryan Day declined to endorse Patricia after the game.

“When you watch a game like this, you’ve got a lot of things that you’ve got to change.”

Day said. “We don’t have a choice. We’ve got to get this thing together next week to go win this game.”

Day added that no staff changes would come before the Michigan game, but “at the end of the year, we’ll evaluate everything and figure out what to do next.”

Ohio state university scratched red

Broader roster and coaching scrutiny

The Athletic reported Ohio State’s roster cost is estimated at $49 million to $54 million, among the highest in college football, yet the team lacks high-end depth. Jeremiah Smith and Jay Timmons are the only true impact players. The offense has averaged 21.7 points in the past three games. Special teams coordinator Robby Discher oversaw a fake punt against Oregon that changed the game.

Questions extend beyond Patricia. Larry Johnson’s defensive line has struggled to generate pressure, and secondary coach Tim Walton’s unit has not met its “Best in America” standard despite a $1.8 million salary. Linebackers coach James Laurinaitis is viewed as safe after producing two top-seven NFL draft picks last season.

Ohio State faces Michigan next week with a 10-2 record and a defense that has forced two punts in its last two games combined.