OIG: Detroit Fire Captain Abused Badge, Threatened to Shut Down Venue

“Anything you can do for me?”

Fire Captain Michael Slater asked, flashing his badge at a Detroit venue security guard on Oct. 4, 2025. When the answer was no, the birthday celebration curdled into a confrontation that ended with Slater threatening to shut the business down, an Office of Inspector General report released Nov. 17 concluded.

The OIG found that Slater, off duty and attending his wife’s birthday party with roughly 20 family members and friends, abused his authority by attempting to bypass the line and metal detectors at an unidentified local venue. His supervisor, Fire Marshal Donald Thomas, then abused his own authority by declining to investigate the venue’s complaint, dismissing it as “basically he said, she said,” the report says.

The Confrontation at the Door

Surveillance footage reviewed by investigators shows Slater approaching security, displaying his Detroit Fire Department credentials, and being directed to the back of the line, which wrapped around the building. When a second employee also refused special treatment, Slater asked about the venue’s occupancy limit.

“Cus even if you’re one over I’ll get this motherfucker shut down,” he told one worker, according to witness statements cited in the 15-page report. FOX 2 Detroit reported a second, sharper threat captured by witnesses: “You better not be 1 guest over or I will get this bitch shut down.”

Slater pushed past the manager on duty and walked through a metal detector that alarmed. Rather than submit to secondary screening, he displayed his badge again and entered the building, forcing security to pull him back.

At the checkpoint a second time, the detector alarmed again. The OIG report describes Slater “dancing” around the equipment while removing his belt and emptying his pockets, creating a scene the venue manager characterized as disruptive.

Detroit fire dept
Photo: fox2detroit.com

A Supervisor’s Blind Eye

The OIG’s criticism extends beyond Slater’s behavior that night. Fire Marshal Donald Thomas received the venue general manager’s complaint through the mayor’s office but conducted no independent investigation. He did not review the surveillance video. He did not interview venue staff.

He accepted Slater’s characterization of the events — that he had merely “flashed his badge to show that he worked for the Fire Marshal Division and that he had noted that there were some violations while he was in line” — and issued only a verbal reprimand the night of the incident.

“Based upon what I know about Captain Slater, I just don’t see him behaving in that manner,” Thomas told investigators. The OIG concluded that Thomas’s “lack of supervisory oversight increases risk of abuse by DFD public servants who report to him, as it allows open disregard for the public and DFD’s policies without fear of any consequences.”

OIG: Detroit Fire Captain Abused Badge, Threatened to Shut Down Venue
Photo: newmediadetroit.com

Competing Narratives

In his OIG interview, Slater framed the episode differently. He said he showed his badge “just to get in after the time of the event start” and asked, “As a courtesy, can I go in to set up?” He described his profane remarks as “tongue-in-cheek” and his demeanor when denied entry as merely “disappointed.” Asked whether such behavior was common for him, he replied, “Everyone loves the fireman.”

Slater also claimed he smelled marijuana inside the venue and suggested security’s resistance was retaliatory. He criticized the OIG for not interviewing the friends and family present that night. Thomas, for his part, insisted he had disciplined Slater verbally and argued the witness testimony was incomplete and the silent surveillance footage “represents an incomplete investigation.”

Department Response and OIG Recommendations

The OIG recommended disciplinary action for both men and mandatory ethics and badge-use training for the entire Fire Marshal Division. The Detroit Fire Department, in a statement to WDIV, pushed back. “The Detroit Fire Department addressed this matter last year through appropriate corrective and disciplinary action,” the department said.

“Following the incident, we also reinforced department-wide training and communication regarding employee badging policies and procedures to ensure expectations are clearly understood and followed. While we have reviewed the findings of the Inspector General’s latest report, they do not warrant any additional disciplinary action beyond what has already been administered.”

Executive Fire Commissioner Chuck Simms signed the response. The department did not specify the discipline already imposed.

The Detroit Fire Department, founded as a professional force on March 26, 1867, operates 47 fire companies and 25 ambulances from 36 stations with roughly 1,200 sworn personnel. It answers about 170,000 calls a year, more than 80% of them medical, and fights an average of six structure fires daily.

Executive Fire Commissioner Chuck Simms, who signed the response to the OIG report, took the permanent post in 2023 after serving as interim commissioner in 2022.

The report lands more than a year after the October 2025 incident, leaving the timeline of accountability unclear. For the venue staff who faced down a badge and a threat, and for a division tasked with enforcing safety codes rather than wielding them for personal convenience, the OIG’s findings suggest the internal checks failed. The Fire Department insists they did not. The gap between those two positions remains the story.