Bentley McCullough left Ophir Elementary on Monday to a gymnasium shaking with handmade posters and students wearing “We love you Bentley” hats, trading her daily work as an American Sign Language interpreter for an eight-day shot at Miss Rodeo America in Las Vegas.
The send-off on Nov. 16 captured the two worlds McCullough bridges: the Big Sky school district where she interprets for a student, and the family ranch near Geraldine where she runs cattle with her sister.
Explore Big Sky reported that if she wins the national title starting Nov. 29, she will resign from Ophir and spend a year as the professional face of rodeo; if she loses, she returns to the classroom in January.
She told Explore Big Sky that the send-off was great motivation, but she was going to miss all of them.
The road from Boston back to the range
McCullough grew up in Geraldine and started learning ASL her senior year of high school. A required visit to the Montana School for the Deaf and Blind introduced her to a young boy who was hard of hearing, an encounter she said cemented her decision to sign for life.
She spent a year at Casper College before transferring to Northeastern University in Boston, where she earned a degree in ASL-English interpreting. In Boston she taught deaf and hearing friends about the cattle industry, worked as a veterinary technician and rode dressage on weekends. “Any ounce of animal interaction I got, I would take,” she said. The city also gave her gratitude for the ranching community she left behind.
After graduating, she returned to Two Sisters Ranch, the family operation she now runs with her sister. She began interpreting for a child in Big Sky and joined the Ophir Elementary staff.
A crown sparked on the Fourth of July
The pageant path began July 4, 2024, when McCullough watched Miss Rodeo Montana ride into the arena in Livingston. “I said, ‘I am going to do that,'” she recalled. Having never competed in a pageant, she was named Miss Rodeo Montana in Waiting in March 2025 and coronated Miss Rodeo Montana 2026 in January. State titleholders automatically advance to the national competition.
Preparation meant daily rides, podcasts, self-reflection and holding down both the interpreting job and ranch duties. “Every day consisted of some sort of improvement toward my goal,” she said. That routine, she added, became “the foundation for everything I need” for the national stage.
Eight days without electronics
The Miss Rodeo America pageant runs Nov. 29 through Dec. 6 in Las Vegas. About 30 contestants are judged on personality, appearance, knowledge and horsemanship. They are chaperoned, receive no coaching and are barred from using electronics, which McCullough said creates an “even playing field.” She hopes judges see three things: her love for the deaf community and passion for accessibility, her faith, and her roots as a Montana-raised cattle rancher.
“It is my life.”
she said of her work with the deaf community.
“At the end of the day, I have to trust it is as it is supposed to be,” McCullough said.