The Orange County School Board approved steep health insurance cost increases on Nov. 13 after an eight-hour hearing, leaving most of the district’s 13,000 teachers facing higher premiums and deductibles that will erase modest pay raises and take effect next year.
The divided board voted to raise rates to keep the district’s self-insured employee benefits trust solvent, rejecting a state magistrate’s compromise plan that would have increased costs by a smaller margin. Orlando Sentinel reported that without changes, the district said it must transfer about $20 million each month from its general budget to prop up the insurance fund.
Premiums and deductibles more than double under new plan
Under the new plan, teachers have ten options. In all but one, premiums and deductibles more than doubled. A single-employee plan remains free of a premium, but its deductible jumps from $300 to $2,000 and excludes Orlando Health, one of the county’s largest providers, from its network.
David Grimm, a 26-year OCPS veteran, said his per-paycheck cost would rise from $27 to $59 if he keeps his current coverage. He may switch to the zero-premium option but would lose the Orlando Health doctors who have treated his chronic neck pain for years.
“People are talking about having to quit and find jobs where they have better insurance,” Grimm said. “They’re not going to be able to cover their families, cover their kids, because of the cost. That’s horrible.”
Take-home pay falls despite raises
The board also approved raises of up to 2.65%, but the insurance hikes mean the vast majority of teachers will bring home less money next year than they do now. Grimm said the retroactive raise dating to the start of the school year is not large enough to offset the message a "no" vote sends. “We don’t agree with any of this,” he said.
Megan Oates, a career and technical education teacher at Orange Technical College, plans to enroll in the zero-premium plan. She warned the higher deductible and a new “deductible first” model will deter teachers from seeking care. “Many will just try to ‘grin and bear it’ and see if issues resolve,” Oates said, “before dipping so far into their own pockets.”
Union urges symbolic rejection
The Orange County Classroom Teachers Association is urging members to vote against ratification. President Clinton McCracken said the frustration is widespread. “They don’t believe that the board has listened to their outcry,” McCracken said.
“This conversation isn’t over. We didn’t get what we wanted in this fight, but we’re not done fighting.” A “no” vote would not stop implementation for the coming year but could pressure the district toward a better option later.
New board members, old mistrust
Three of the five board members who voted for the increases left the board after this month’s election; new members were sworn in Tuesday. Angie Gallo, who became chair Tuesday and voted against the hikes, called the situation a “perfect storm” of rising costs, inflation and declining enrollment.
She wants to ask the Florida Legislature to let OCPS join the state health plan, which has lower premiums but is currently limited to small districts. Gallo also proposed moving money from the capital budget — typically reserved for construction — into the general fund, a step that would require state approval but has precedent from the 2008 recession.
Oates said she is “cautiously optimistic” about the new board but remains wary. Most members who approved the increases were once endorsed by the teachers union. “It’s hard to put trust in people at this point,” she said.