The Indianapolis Colts shut down wide receiver Alec Pierce for the remainder of the season on Sunday, the latest move in a midseason teardown that has left the franchise 3-8 and drawn a public indictment from former punter Pat McAfee.
McAfee, who played his entire NFL career in Indianapolis from 2009 to 2016, posted on X that the team had repeatedly done “the right thing” for departing veterans while neglecting the franchise itself.
“Do the right thing. Just like The Colts did ‘the right thing’ for DeForest Buckner and got fleeced. and did ‘the right thing’ for Daniel Jones. and did ‘the right thing’ for Josh Downs. and ‘the right thing’ for Keenan Allen. and ‘the right thing’ for Ed Dodds. Are they ever just gonna worry about doing ‘the right thing’ for their multi billion dollar franchise? Alll eyes are on TBD,” McAfee wrote.
The post came after NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport characterized the Pierce decision as the Colts doing “the right thing” with an eye on a fully healthy 2027, ProFootballNetwork reported.
Pierce re-signed in March on a four-year, $114 million contract that included $84 million in guarantees, with $60 million fully guaranteed at signing, according to ProFootballNetwork. He aggravated his left heel in a September loss to the Kansas City Chiefs — the same heel that required offseason surgery — and had initially planned to rehab rather than undergo another operation.
The shutdown follows a string of personnel moves that began when owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon fired general manager Chris Ballard on October 19 after a 2-4 start. “As I said at the start of the season, the sense of urgency has never been higher. Our standard is to compete for championships, and I believe a change in leadership is necessary to meet that standard,” Irsay-Gordon said at the time, per Yahoo Sports.
Interim general manager Ed Dodds traded Buckner to the San Francisco 49ers for a 2027 fourth-round pick on October 27, then sent Downs and a 2027 seventh-round pick to the Kansas City Chiefs for fourth- and fifth-round picks, and dealt Allen to the 49ers for a 2027 sixth-round pick, all before the November 10 deadline, Yahoo Sports and ProFootballNetwork reported.
The Colts released quarterback Daniel Jones on Friday, one day after a 26-3 loss in Houston dropped them to 3-8. Jones had signed a two-year, $88 million deal in March 2026 worth up to $100 million with incentives after guiding Indianapolis to a 7-1 start in 2025 before a fractured fibula and torn Achilles ended his season, Yahoo Sports reported. He posted career-worst efficiency across 11 starts in 2026, leading the NFL in turnovers, and was benched in the fourth quarter against the Texans after completing 12 of 27 passes for 144 yards and an interception.
Coach Shane Steichen announced the release and named Anthony Richardson the starter the next day. Asked whether Jones had requested his release, Steichen said: “No, this was a decision that was just made for the best interests of both parties.” When pressed on whether the move was designed to let Jones sign elsewhere, Steichen answered: “I’ll keep all those private,” per ProFootballNetwork.
Yahoo Sports reported the Colts had fielded trade inquiries for Jones from the Baltimore Ravens and Minnesota Vikings but “slow-played” them before waiving him 10 days later.
The Colts host the New York Giants on November 29 at 1 p.m. ET, entering as 33% favorites with playoff odds below 1%, according to A to Z Sports.
More on Colts
“Do the right thing.” Just like The Colts did “the right thing” for Deforest Buckner and got fleeced. and did “the right thing” for Daniel Jones. and “the right thing” for Josh Downs. and “the right thing” for Keenan Allen. and “the right thing” for Ed Dodds Are they ever…
The #Colts do the right thing, shutting WR Alec Pierce down for season, with all eyes on a fully healthy 2027. My story on Pierce: https://t.co/u5JVfH900rhttps://t.co/u5JVfH900r
😬 Daniel Jones in 11 games with the Colts this year: 🔵 62.1 PFN QB Impact grade (34th of 35 qualified NFL QBs) 🔵 -0.23 EPA per dropback (T-33rd) 🔵 38.8% success rate (31st) 🔵 3.6 net yards per attempt (34th) 🔵 -6.1 CPOE (T-33rd) He just signed a two-year, $88M deal this… pic.twitter.com/DddbRg05B6