Pennsylvania Supreme Court: Employers Must Prove No Job Vacancies Exist Before Using Labor Market Surveys to Cut Benefits

Pennsylvania employers must now prove they have no available jobs for injured workers before using labor market surveys to cut benefits, the state Supreme Court ruled on Monday.

Sysco Foods reverses the Commonwealth Court and reinstates a Workers’ Compensation Judge’s denial of the company’s modification petition. The ruling places the burden of proof squarely on the employer to demonstrate, by a preponderance of the evidence, that no specific job vacancy exists. “Employer itself has the ‘peculiar means of knowledge’ of its current employment capacity,” the court wrote. “Whether a multinational employer with entire departments dedicated towards staffing concerns, or a simple mom-and-pop shop, only the employer itself has the ‘peculiar means of knowledge’ of its current employment capacity.”

The case involved a forklift operator who suffered a lower left leg amputation and adjustment disorder. Sysco Foods sought to reduce his weekly benefits from $978 to $549.18 based on a labor market survey asserting an earning power of $660 per week. The survey did not identify a specific available position with the employer. A Workers’ Compensation Judge denied the petition, finding Sysco failed to prove no light-duty jobs were available.

The Workers’ Compensation Appeal Board and Commonwealth Court reversed, ruling the claimant bore the burden to show a job opening existed. The Supreme Court rejected that framework. It held that Section 306(b)(2) of the Workers’ Compensation Act requires an employer to offer any available job vacancy before relying on general labor market data. Because the employer possesses “superior knowledge and access to evidence” regarding its own vacancies, the burden of proving nonexistence rests with the company.

The court noted a worker would be at a “unique disadvantage” trying to gather such information from external sources like job postings or depositions. Conversely, it said the burden is “relatively easy for the employer to satisfy” because an HR employee’s testimony that no jobs exist may be sufficient for a judge. The matter is remanded for reinstatement of the WCJ’s order. Workerscompensation.com reported the decision.