Phillips County Appeals Ruling Ordering Retirement Payments for Nita Murray

Phillips County is appealing a circuit judge’s ruling that it must pay decades of retirement contributions for a former prosecutor’s office employee kept off the official payroll for nearly three decades.

Retired Circuit Judge Robert Bynum Gibson Jr. found that Nita Murray was a county employee from Sept. 1, 1993, through her retirement on Dec. 31, 2021, and ordered the county to remit unpaid contributions to the Arkansas Public Employees Retirement System. The county filed its notice of appeal on Oct. 22, challenging the October judgment and related orders.

Murray filed the lawsuit in April 2023 after working for then-Prosecuting Attorney Fletcher Long and later for Prosecuting Attorney Todd Murray, her husband. She kept trial records, interviewed witnesses and served as the office’s primary contact for law enforcement.

“The arrangement was intended to keep Murray off the county payroll and deny her retirement coverage,” Gibson wrote in his findings. The judge determined the county appropriated money for Murray’s salary but classified it as “Supplies,” paying the funds to Todd Murray, who then paid his wife.

Phillips County Appeals Ruling Ordering Retirement Payments for Nita Murray
Photo: arkansasonline.com

The budget maneuver

Gibson pointed to a $15,125 budget line for supplies — an amount he found represented Murray’s pay rather than actual supply needs for an office with one support staffer. The judge also found Murray worked in the courthouse, held keys and received the county employee manual when she started.

Former Prosecuting Attorney Fletcher Long testified about repeated friction with the Quorum Court over funding. Gibson cited a 2007 letter in which Long complained the county had reduced the prosecutor’s budget to an amount sufficient for only one month of operations. The judge further found Murray was denied janitorial services and her office was allowed to become infested with mold and mildew.

Discrimination findings

Gibson concluded the payroll arrangement was motivated by race. He relied in part on a 1999 Quorum Court resolution directing elected officials to hire Black applicants to fill vacancies, stating an objective of racial equality in the county workforce. Gibson interpreted the resolution as excluding white applicants and found it supported his conclusion about the county’s treatment of Murray, who is white.

The judge also cited an earlier Equal Employment Opportunity Commission determination involving other white county employees. County attorneys disputed that evidence, arguing in a July brief that the resolution was unsigned by the county judge and clerk, had no legal effect and had not been shown to cause any action against Murray. They also argued the EEOC matter involved other people and did not mention Murray.

Gibson rejected the argument that the missing signatures invalidated the resolution, finding the Quorum Court had adopted it by acclamation. Murray’s attorneys argued the resolution came from the county clerk’s official records and was relevant to motive and intent.

Procedural history

Gibson’s 13-page factual findings were filed Sept. 17, following a June 9 bench trial. A final declaratory judgment and writ of mandamus incorporating those findings was entered Oct. 1. The judgment ordered the county to appropriate and remit unpaid retirement contributions, along with any applicable penalties, interest or present-day value determined by APERS.

The county’s Oct. 22 notice of appeal sends the case to the Arkansas Court of Appeals. A briefing schedule has not yet been set.