Poll: Three-Quarters of PA Democratic Voters View Fetterman Unfavorably

Three quarters of Pennsylvania Democratic voters now view their own senator unfavorably, a September Inquirer, New York Times and Siena University poll found, and the first declared challenger for his 2028 seat is a Palestinian-American writer born in Rafah who calls Israel’s war in Gaza a genocide.

Sen. John Fetterman, 57, has spent his first term voting for President Donald Trump’s nominees, cutting a video for the Republican midterm convention, and telling donors he would leave the Democratic Party if it adopts an anti-Israel platform. Republicans have said they would welcome him. Democrats, emboldened by a midterm cycle that gave them at least 54 Senate seats, are lining up alternatives.

Ahmed Moor, 42, a West Philadelphia resident and former finance professional at Swiss Re Capital Markets, announced his candidacy the week after Election Day. Born in Rafah, he moved to Philadelphia as a child and recently served as a committeeperson in the Philadelphia Democratic City Committee.

He supports cutting U.S. military aid to Israel and imposing sanctions until Palestinians have equal rights. “I’m not really running against Fetterman,” Moor told the Philadelphia Inquirer. “I’m running for good government. I’m running for the rule of law. I’m running because I believe in America.” The Guardian reported that Moor previously wrote for that outlet.

Ahmed Moor Launches 2028 Senate Campaign Against John Fetterman in Pennsylvania — Capitol Signal

The Pittsburgh contender building a war chest

A member of the Congressional Progressive Caucus endorsed by Bernie Sanders and the Working Families Party, Deluzio also attended a centrist Democratic summit in Denver and helped found the New Economic Patriots, a populist caucus focused on corporate accountability.

“Can my family support this? Can I win? And will I be the best damn senator possible?” Deluzio told the Inquirer. “If the answer to any of those things is not a resounding yes, then I won’t go do this.”

Two former rivals watching the numbers

Conor Lamb and Malcolm Kenyatta, who lost to Fetterman in the 2022 primary with 26% and 11% respectively, have not ruled out returns. Lamb, 42, a former Marine prosecutor who flipped a Pittsburgh-area House seat in 2018, has held more than a dozen town halls across the state since 2025 and criticized Fetterman’s vote against a resolution requiring congressional approval for military action in Iran.

“He’s gone a long way on vibes, finally meets an issue that requires the input of serious people and he talks about bombing and killing like it’s a video game,” Lamb posted on X. “I would say it’s embarrassing but if you think about the human lives involved it’s far worse than that.”

Kenyatta, 36, now the Democratic National Committee vice chair, celebrated the midterm Senate majority on social media: “We just Fetterman proofed the US Senate.”

A historic opening for women

Pennsylvania has never elected a woman to the U.S. Senate. Five current or former House members — all women — are openly considering the race. U.S. Rep. Madeleine Dean, 67, told Politico on November 10 she is “considering” a run, citing disappointment with Fetterman’s votes and concern for his health and family.

Dean ran against Fetterman for lieutenant governor in 2018 before pivoting to Congress. “When I say consider, nothing is lighthearted,” she told Politico. USA Today noted her background founding the PA-SAFE Caucus on gun violence after the Sandy Hook shooting and her service on the House Appropriations and Foreign Affairs committees.

U.S. Rep. Chrissy Houlahan, 59, said Senator Dave McCormick, a Republican, has been easier to work with than Fetterman. “It’s no secret that I’ve been disappointed with some of his votes and that I’m confused by it,” she told Punchbowl News in April.

Former Rep. Susan Wild, 69, who lost her Lehigh Valley seat in 2024, wrote on X in March: “People worked so hard for Fetterman and he kicked them in the teeth. On to 2028 when we elect a real Dem.” U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, a Pittsburgh progressive and Squad member, has also been floated.

Us news one wouldbe fetterman primary challenger ha
Photo: mcall.com

The name that isn’t running

U.S. Rep. Brendan Boyle, an outspoken Fetterman critic who consulted advisors about a Senate bid, announced this month he will stay in the House as incoming chairman of the Budget Committee.

Fetterman began his political career as the part-time mayor of Braddock, a former steel town where he moved in 2004 and won his first election by a single vote in 2005. He served there until 2019, when he became lieutenant governor, and won the U.S. Senate seat in 2022 with 51% of the vote.

Fetterman’s next move

The senator has not said whether he will seek a second term, or under which banner. He has increasingly relied on Republican fundraising structures, including a joint committee with McCormick.

Gov. Josh Shapiro told NBC after the midterms that if Fetterman runs again, “he has a lot of work to do earn the trust of people of Pennsylvania. He’s got to show up, and he should speak to the people of Pennsylvania about what his plans are.”

John Fetterman Faces First 2028 Senate Primary Challenger: Who Is Ahmed Moor? — Ottumwa Radio