A Portland hearings officer has approved Portland General Electric’s revised plan to cut more than 370 trees in Forest Park, reviving a transmission project the City Council unanimously rejected last year.
The decision, issued Friday by hearings officer Marisha Childs, came more than four months after the city and the utility reached a mediation agreement that environmental groups called a “backroom deal.”
The Forest Park Conservancy said it will likely appeal the decision to the City Council before the Dec. 4 deadline, and the utility welcomed the ruling as a “thorough and reasoned review.” Oregon Live reported that Childs agreed with PGE and city staff that the transmission work is necessary to prevent potential power outages as electricity demand grows, and that no feasible alternative route causing less environmental harm exists.
Last year, the City Council voted unanimously to deny PGE’s permits for the Harborton Reliability Project after a previous hearings officer had approved it.
PGE appealed that rejection to the Oregon Land Use Board of Appeals, then put the appeal on hold to enter mediation with the city and three nonprofits: the Forest Park Conservancy, the Bird Alliance of Oregon — headquartered in Forest Park — and the Forest Park Neighborhood Association, according to focalnews.org.
Those groups participated in early discussions but said they were excluded from the final round of negotiations that produced the agreement. “There are lawyers that have provided testimony. One worked for the Bonneville Power Administration and claims that demand model is faulty, that others don’t agree that need is clear,” Carole Hardy, a board member with the Forest Park Conservancy, told KPTV in October.
“And the growing demand in Portland is coming from data centers, not residential households, which is where they’re threatening blackout. So the transparency is not there. We still claim they haven’t proven need. There’s alternative routes that haven’t been fully explored.”

The mediation agreement committed PGE to $5.5 million for environmental mitigation within or adjacent to Forest Park — $3.1 million more than the utility had promised in its original application. Childs imposed additional requirements: a large portion of that money must be reserved for and spent specifically within the project area, and PGE must conduct pre-construction wildlife surveys and establish timing restrictions to protect amphibians.
Childs also addressed allegations that the mediation agreement resulted from “backdoor dealings” or “pay to play” arrangements. “These assertions are both outside the scope of the approval criteria and beyond the scope of the Hearings Officer,” Childs wrote, adding that she had independently evaluated the revised proposal on its merits.
The Harborton Reliability Project entails rewiring an existing 1970s transmission line and adding a second line within PGE’s existing right-of-way through the 5,200-acre park.
The utility says the work is needed to avoid potential power outages in North and Northwest Portland, with demand growth that could trigger reliability issues as soon as 2028. The revised proposal would remove roughly the same number of trees as the original plan, though it includes changes intended to reduce construction impacts.
“PGE appreciates the hearings officer’s decision, which reflects a thorough and reasoned review of our application, staff’s report and all testimony and evidence from PGE, city staff, intervenors and others,” spokesperson Andrea Platt said via email.
Last time, they said no.