Pro-Israel Lawyers Challenge Bookstore Cancellation of Zionist Poetry Reading

UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI) has formally questioned Typewronger Books regarding its choice to scrap a poetry gathering after getting grievances that its Jewish host had shared racist and Zionist verses in other locations.

UK Lawyers for Israel wrote to the Edinburgh bookshop last Monday on behalf of Jewish poet Tracey S. Rosenberg, contending that calling off her Dead Poets’ Slam likely constituted unlawful discrimination under the Equality Act 2010. The dispute unfolded after the venue pulled the plug on the early December competition.

The event was designed as a contest where performers would impersonate deceased poets and recite their work, with Rosenberg scheduled to host the evening as Dorothy Parker, the acclaimed American poet. Typewronger Books initially welcomed the proposal, called it an excellent idea, and advertised it on Eventbrite while performers signed up for slots.

Safeguarding concerns and political statements

The bookshop contacted Rosenberg on October 19, stating it had received complaints about potential safeguarding issues. The reports maintained that she had recited racist and Zionist poems at alternative Edinburgh open mic gatherings and accused fellow poets of antisemitism for employing the expression “free Palestine.”

In its email to Rosenberg, Typewronger Books said that it did not want to create the impression that it supported Israel. “The perception that we’d support the State of Israel in the atrocities it has perpetrated on the Palestinians is not one we would welcome,” the bookshop wrote.

“There can be no ambiguity here – what Israel has done is wrong. ‘Free Palestine’ is very much the opinion of those who work here and our wider community, which includes several Jewish people and is in no way antisemitic,” the email read.

When Rosenberg asked for a phone call, Typewronger Books insisted on corresponding via email, noting it trusted its stance was clear and requesting Rosenberg to outline her own. Typewronger Books declined to pursue the matter further and called off the event less than two hours after initially bringing up the complaints.

Legal challenges and disputed accounts

Rosenberg pointed out three poems concerning Israel and her Jewish heritage that she had delivered at spoken word sessions addressing October 7, antisemitism in Britain, and anti-Israel demonstrations, pointing out that none of them contained racism. UKLFI argued that Zionism, viewed as the aspiration of the Jewish people for self-determination within their ancestral land, enjoys protection as a philosophical belief pursuant to the Equality Act 2010.

“It is alarming that a Jewish poet’s event could be canceled simply because someone complained that her poetry was ‘Zionist,’” a UKLFI spokesperson said, adding that the poet was apparently expected to demonstrate agreement with the bookshop’s political position on Israel.

Typewronger Books denied discrimination in its response letter to UKLFI on Tuesday. Tee Hodges, the head and founder of Typewronger CIC, said that the initial grievance came anonymously from an individual professing to be Jewish. Hodges claimed that other individuals had backed up the grievances concerning Rosenberg, citing hostile conduct, walking out on fellow poets, and fostering a disagreeable environment.

However, UKLFI said that Typewronger Books provided neither the original complaint nor supporting evidence despite its requests. Hodges claimed that Rosenberg failed to engage and that a communication breakdown was the sole reason for cancellation. Rosenberg strongly disputed this account, stating she responded promptly and rejected allegations of aggression.

Typewronger Books did not respond to The Jerusalem Post’s request for comment by publication time.

Israel: Lawyers Challenge Netanyahu's Election as Prime Minister — AP Archive