“Probably some more packs!” Lucas Martell said when asked what the brothers would buy first with their winnings.
Two Connecticut brothers who bought three $30 boxes of Topps NFL Bowman cards at a Target on October 15 pulled a one-of-one “Bejeweled Brady” Garbage Pail Kids Superfractor from the pack they agreed to open together in the parking lot, Boston.com reported. The card, authenticated by Certified Guaranty Company, headlines the Fanatics Collect Premier Auction that closes November 19; bidding reached $32,000 as of Thursday afternoon.
The Martell brothers — Lucas, 18, and Trevor, 23, of Griswold — took the card to The Treasure Chest, a collectibles shop in Old Mystick Village that opened about two months ago. Owner Carmine LaRusso recognized the card was beyond his store’s level. “I knew it was a bigger card than what I would ever put in the store myself, so I knew it had to go to professionals,” he told WSFB.
Superfractors are printed as one-of-one cards, meaning only a single copy exists. Antique Trader reported this is the only Bejeweled Brady Superfractor in the Bowman release. The card depicts Brady in a Tampa Bay Buccaneers uniform surrounded by red-and-black confetti, wearing seven Super Bowl rings — one for each win — on a hand drawn with seven fingers to accommodate them all, artwork by longtime Garbage Pail Kids artist Dave Gross.

The math behind the pull
Mathematical estimates put the odds of pulling this specific card at one in 10.5 million, according to Sports.Yahoo.com. The same pack also contained a Drake Maye “Etched in Glass” card worth roughly $200, Lucas Martell said. “We kind of like lost it right then and there,” he told the outlet. “I knew it was a special card, but I didn’t realize how special it was until afterwards.”
LaRusso believes the final price could go far higher. “I believe it’s a quarter million to half a million card,” he told WSFB. A comparable one-of-one Garbage Pail Kids Superfractor of Cooper Flagg sold for $288,000 earlier this year, making it the most expensive Garbage Pail Kids card of all time, according to Topps. Brady cards have climbed as high as $3.1 million.
The auction structure negotiated by LaRusso and Clay Thomas of Fanatics Collect gives Lucas Martell 115% of the final winning bid — the full sale price plus an additional 75% of the auction house’s 20% buyer’s premium, according to a news release cited by Sports.Yahoo.com.
Fanatics offered an advance of up to 50% of its minimum assessed card value with an underlying valuation of at least $150,000. The card was shipped to Los Angeles with $350,000 in insurance coverage and will be professionally graded by Beckett Grading Services before the auction concludes.
A market that keeps rewriting its own ceiling
The sports card market has exploded in recent years. Just this year, a 2026 Topps Chrome Ohtani Dual Gold Logoman card sold for $11 million while a 2025-26 Topps Chrome Update NBA Debut Patch Auto from Cooper Flagg fetched just over $8 million, Sports.Yahoo.com reported.
Topps brought Garbage Pail Kids into baseball releases in 2024 and expanded to NBA, NFL, and NIL college athletes in Bowman brand packs this year — basketball in April, football in September.
The Martell brothers show off their find in front of The Treasure Chest shop. Image source: WFSB
Lucas Martell said he recently got into collecting while his brother has been a longtime fan. The money from the sale will be life-altering: Lucas said he has faced high medical bills without proper insurance from an ER visit, and his Jeep has broken down and needs work. Once those debts are paid off, he said, he plans to buy a house.

A watch party for the auction is scheduled for November 14 at the Treasure Chest of Mystic with Savannah Bananas’ Trystan Levesque making an appearance.
Tom Brady, born in 1977 in San Mateo, California, was selected 199th overall by the New England Patriots in the 2000 NFL Draft. He holds NFL records for career passing yards, completions, touchdown passes, and quarterback wins, and is the only player to win Super Bowl MVP for two different franchises.
“Probably some more packs!” Lucas Martell said when asked what the brothers would buy first with their winnings.