Providence Chief Operating Officer Dr. Darryl Elmouchi warns that the swelling ranks of aging Americans will force a fundamental overhaul of how the nation pays for and delivers health care.
“We’re not going to have enough money to pay for it the way the system works,” he told Chief Healthcare Executive.
The math is straightforward and unforgiving. As millions roll off commercial insurance and onto Medicare, hospitals lose the cross-subsidy that has kept the lights on for decades. Government payers, primarily Medicare, pay less than the cost of delivering care for almost every patient. Commercial insurance has historically made up the difference. That model breaks when the commercial pool shrinks and the Medicare pool grows.
Elmouchi sees value-based care as the only viable exit ramp. He points to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services as the primary engine of that shift. “CMS is going to keep on pushing, and I think that’s a good thing,” he said. “What they say goes, and so it’ll cause widespread adoption.”
There is a structural advantage to Medicare’s longevity, he argues. Commercial insurers churn patients year to year, making long-term prevention a bad investment. Medicare holds populations for decades, aligning the payer’s incentive with the patient’s health five or ten years out. That horizon changes what interventions make financial sense.
Elmouchi says he hopes to see more adoption of value-based care, but he says, “It has to be the right adoption, and there’s no one model that works forever.” He adds that value-based care requires a lot of expertise, a lot of good data and time, and you have to be able to experiment and get pilots going and make them work.
Providence operates 51 hospitals and 1,000 clinics across multiple states. Even at that scale, the transition is perilous. Jumping into a value-based arrangement without mature data infrastructure and clinical workflows can inflict severe financial damage. That risk has made many systems skittish.
The data problem is existential. Patient records live in fragmented silos across hospital networks, private practices, and competing health systems. Assembling a longitudinal view of a single patient — necessary to predict and prevent an adverse event years later — is a herculean integration task.
Elmouchi believes artificial intelligence is the key to unlocking that data. “At the end of the day, there almost is too much data, and it’s so disaggregated,” he said.
“If AI can help us get that data together, really look at it the proper way, and give the right nudges, it might be the secret. I don’t think it’s going to be the only solution, but it’ll definitely be a solution.”
The stakes extend far beyond hospital balance sheets. If the payment model collapses without a replacement, access narrows — especially for the elderly and chronically ill who need continuous, coordinated care most.
Value-based care promises to align payment with outcomes, but the operational lift is massive. The next decade will test whether health systems can build the data architecture and clinical discipline to make that promise real before the demographic wave breaks.