Rejected Ballots Leave Mississippi HBCU Students Feeling Disenfranchised

Hundreds of students at Tougaloo College and Jackson State University cast provisional ballots on Election Day that were ultimately tossed out, leaving a generation of first-time voters feeling the sting of disenfranchisement in a state with a long history of suppressing Black ballots.

The rejected ballots surfaced even as Democrat Scott Colom clinched a historic victory over incumbent Republican Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith, making him Mississippi’s first Black U.S. senator since Reconstruction.

But the win did little to dull the frustration on campus, where organizers had registered at least 70 students using their on-campus addresses only to watch the system discard their votes over technicalities — some as mundane as a county line running through a dormitory.

“We’re like, oh shoot, we are actually making a difference.”

Muarib Abdul-Tawwab, an 18-year-old Tougaloo freshman, told Yahoo News, recalling the energy on campus before the count turned. “Then you find out your vote didn’t count.”

The mechanism of the rejection was bureaucratic but the impact was surgical. Tougaloo’s campus straddles Hinds and Madison counties; the dorms sit in Madison, while other buildings fall in Hinds. Many students — and even the student body president, Aznii Welchlin — had no idea the split existed.

When they registered using a campus address, some listed the wrong county. In Hinds County alone, officials received 2,426 affidavit ballots and rejected more than half, a county Resolution Board member told Mississippi Public Broadcasting Online.

Compounding the confusion, Mississippi does not allow online voter registration. Students filled out paper forms by hand, introducing spelling errors and address mismatches that election officials used to invalidate ballots. Some students presented valid student IDs — legal under state law, according to the Southern Coalition for Social Justice — and were turned away anyway.

“It is appalling the number of issues that we’ve seen, and we had on Election Day, and now we’re seeing the extension of that post-Election Day in a way that is not great.”

Lydia Grizzell, policy and advocacy manager for the ACLU of Mississippi, told Capital B. She noted there was no uniform counting process across counties, and in some jurisdictions the tabulation happened behind closed doors.

The episode reflects a deeper structural friction. Since the U.S. Supreme Court gutted key provisions of the Voting Rights Act, Republican-led legislatures have redrawn maps and tightened rules that disproportionately affect Black voters.

Welchlin said her mentors — alumni of Tougaloo’s civil-rights heyday — had never heard of the county-line issue either. “She pointed to the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision this year to gut parts of the Voting Rights Act, which opened the door for Republicans to redraw maps ahead of the midterms,” Yahoo reported.

Rejected Ballots Leave Mississippi HBCU Students Feeling Disenfranchised

Abdul-Tawwab, who is from out of state, framed the stakes bluntly to his peers: “If you don’t think your vote matters, it does matter. But I say your vote matters more in Mississippi than it does where you’re from. … Where you’re from probably has a better, healthier voting practice than Mississippi does.”

The fight now shifts to the runoffs on Dec. 1, including contests for Mississippi House Districts 70 and 77 and a special general runoff for the 7th Circuit Court district attorney in Hinds County. Welchlin and the Mississippi Access Project — a student-led coalition founded by Jackson State activist Jakari Holland — are pushing for online registration and same-day registration to modernize the state’s infrastructure. They are also re-registering students whose ballots were rejected.

On Nov. 11, Colom delivered his victory speech at Tougaloo. “Many students, this was their first time voting and they were very discouraged,” Welchlin said. “They were really excited that they got to vote or tried to vote, and because of that, we’re going to get them re-registered.”