The Rhode Island House Judiciary Committee unanimously advanced Superior Court Judge Luis Matos toward a lifetime seat on the state Supreme Court on Tuesday, sending the nomination to the full House for a Dec. 1 vote despite allegations from a former partner that he once pressured her against having an abortion.
Matos, 62, told lawmakers he has supported a woman’s right to choose for many years, acknowledging his views have shifted. “That wasn’t always my perspective,” he said. “But that is my perspective today and that’s my personal opinion — I am not making any statement about what the law is and what the law is not,” Rhode Island Current reported.
The nomination, submitted by Gov. Dan McKee on Nov. 4, triggered a 60-day window for legislative action. A Senate confirmation vote would follow House approval.
Hearing focuses on abortion allegations against nominee
The hearing centered on an Oct. 10 email from Amanda Nelson of Baltimore to both judiciary committees. Nelson wrote that she became pregnant during a 1994 relationship with Matos in Washington, D.C., and that he urged her not to terminate the pregnancy, later declining her offer to raise the child alone. She described his stance at the time as “extreme” pro-life.
Committee Chairwoman Carol Hagan McEntee pressed Matos on whether the account raised concerns about how he would adjudicate reproductive rights. “We fought long and hard for the right to choose, for the women’s reproductive rights in this body,” McEntee said.
Matos replied that he has long kept personal opinions private to preserve both impartiality and its appearance. “I have always endeavored to not let my opinions, whatever they might be, be the focus of any kind of public discussion,” he said.
He then affirmed his current position: “I have for a long time supported a woman’s right to choose and that wasn’t always my perspective. I acknowledge that. But that is my perspective today.”

Nelson did not appear at the hearing.
Judicial experience and bipartisan praise
A parade of judges testified for Matos, including Supreme Court Chief Justice Paul Suttell, Superior Court Chief Joseph Montalbano, and Justice Erin Lynch Prata. Lynch Prata, a former Senate Judiciary chair, shepherded the 2019 law codifying Roe v. Wade protections into state statute before the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe in a 6-to-3 ruling in 2022.
In a unanimous vote, the RI House Judiciary Committee approved Gov. McKee’s nomination of Judge Luis Matos to the Rhode Island Supreme Court. The nomination will now go before the full House. https://t.co/3VnCzHYeG8
Supporters emphasized Matos’ criminal court experience — unique among current justices — and his work on a racial fairness committee created after George Floyd’s murder in 2020. The Alliance for Justice, a coalition of over 140 civil rights groups, wrote in “strong support” of his “extensive judicial experience, unique perspective, and demonstrated commitment to equal justice under law.”
Matos, who immigrated from Portugal at age 5 speaking no English, traced his path from Fox Point’s Portuguese community through Brown University and a federal prosecutorship to the Superior Court bench since 2012. He noted he ran his first marathon at 60.
“I never lost the sensation, the utter sense of pride when I would walk into the courtroom the first time … and I stood in front of the judge and I introduced myself and I said that I was there to represent the United States of America,” Matos told lawmakers.
“I went to a place that was in my old neighborhood’s backyard, but could not have been further from any universe that I was familiar with at the time,” he said.
Gov.
Nominee declines to address pending clergy abuse cases
McEntee also asked whether pending clergy sexual abuse cases — filed under a two-year revival window she championed — should go directly to the Supreme Court for a constitutional ruling. “It frankly depends on the case, and I can’t speak to that unless I have an actual case in controversy in front of me,” Matos said, repeating the answer when pressed.
Matos did not directly address the question.
Confidentiality of investigative materials
House Speaker Christopher Blazejewski and Senate President Valarie Lawson declined to release letters from the investigative packet, citing confidentiality of tax returns and background checks. “Witness testimony concerning all judicial nominees is conducted at the hearing, in person, and under oath,” they wrote.
Retired Superior Court Judge Edward Clifton made public a supportive letter from the Ministers Alliance of Rhode Island that had been withheld, praising Matos for “professionalism, dignity and respect” in community jury outreach.
The full House votes Dec. 1.