RI House Panel Advances Matos Nomination After He Affirms Abortion Rights Support

Rhode Island Supreme Court nominee Luis M. Matos affirmed his support for abortion rights on Tuesday, telling lawmakers he has considered himself pro-choice for many years as he seeks a lifetime appointment on the state’s highest bench, according to News From The States.

“That wasn’t always my perspective,” the 62-year-old nominee told members of the House Committee on Judiciary. “But that is my perspective today and that’s my personal opinion — I am not making any statement about what the law is and what the law is not.”

Those assurances persuaded the Democratic chair of the House Judiciary Committee to join the panel in unanimously advancing Matos’ nomination to the full chamber for consideration. Governor Dan McKee nominated Matos in August to fill the seat vacated by Justice Maureen McKenna Goldberg, who retired in March after almost 29 years on the bench.

The nomination was formally submitted to the House and Senate for advice and consent Nov. 4, triggering a 60-day window for lawmakers in both chambers to act. The full House is scheduled to vote on Matos’ nomination Dec. 1, while the Senate Judiciary Committee is scheduled to hold a hearing Nov. 30.

RI House Panel Advances Matos Nomination After He Affirms Abortion Rights Support
Photo: rhodeislandcurrent.com

Questions Over Past Relationship

Before Matos’ formal nomination, members of the House and Senate judiciary committees received an email from a Baltimore woman who became pregnant while dating Matos in the 1990s and claimed he had opposed her decision to have an abortion.

The Oct. 10 email from Amanda Nelson to the committees described her relationship with Matos in Washington, D.C., in 1994, when she said she became pregnant and he urged her not to have an abortion, News From The States reported.

Nelson said she ultimately terminated the pregnancy after Matos declined her offer to raise the child as a single father. In October, the woman wrote to legislators saying Matos “expressed extreme anti-choice rhetoric and demonstrated a profound lack of personal accountability,” according to The Boston Globe.

Rep. Carol Hagan McEntee, a South Kingstown Democrat who chairs the House Committee on Judiciary, asked Matos whether Nelson’s account called into question his personal views on reproductive rights and whether lawmakers should have concerns about how he might defend or adjudicate those rights as a Supreme Court justice.

“We fought long and hard for the right to choose, for the women’s reproductive rights in this body,” McEntee said.

Matos responded that he had tried throughout his career as a prosecutor, civil servant and judge to keep his personal opinions out of public discussion. He said that was important both to ensure he ruled impartially and to maintain the appearance of impartiality.

RI House Panel Advances Matos Nomination After He Affirms Abortion Rights Support
Photo: bostonglobe.com

Judges Endorse Matos; House Vote Set Dec. 1

Top federal and state judges submitted letters of support for Matos’ nomination, telling legislators he is eminently qualified to serve on the state’s high court. Rhode Island Supreme Court Chief Justice Paul Suttell highlighted Matos’ work on the Judiciary’s Committee on Racial and Ethnic Fairness in the Courts during the hearing.

“Justice Matos has demonstrated an intellectual honesty throughout his judicial career,” Suttell told the committee.

The full House is scheduled to vote on Matos’ nomination Dec. 1.