Sacramento’s Fab 40s will keep its horse-drawn carriages this holiday season after the city manager pulled a proposed emergency ban from Tuesday’s council agenda.
The move preserves a decades-old tradition — and the primary income stream for a local operator — while the city searches for a traffic plan that satisfies both visitors and residents who say gridlock traps them in their driveways for hours.
The item landed on the Nov. 12 agenda as an emergency ordinance that would have prohibited horse-drawn vehicles for hire in the “East Sacramento Holiday Zone” — the area between 35th and 48th streets from Folsom Boulevard to J Street — from Nov. 21 through Jan. 2.
City staff cited traffic obstruction and the unpredictable nature of spooked horses, pointing to a Dec. 26, 2023, incident in which a carriage horse startled by fireworks jumped a curb and landed in a resident’s yard, according to The Sacramento Bee.
Councilmember Phil Pluckebaum, who represents the 4th District, said Monday the proposal was withdrawn after “overwhelming public input and the need to do some additional staff work and digging.” By Tuesday morning, City Manager Maraskeshia Smith had formally requested the item’s removal. “It is highly unlikely the proposal will come before the council again this holiday season,” Pluckebaum said.

“If a horse-drawn carriage is unsafe, it’s unsafe everywhere it’s used.”
Dianna Newborn, owner of Top Hand Ranch Carriage Company, said she was blindsided. Her five carriages had already passed city safety inspections and veterinary clearances in October. “I could not understand why it was there in the first place,” Newborn told CapRadio.
“I jump through any hoop that they ask me to do. Why am I going through all this process if you’re trying to ban me?” The holiday season accounts for the bulk of her annual revenue. “This time of year. This is our main business,” she told KCRA 3.
The Dec. 26 incident involved one of Newborn’s teams. She argues the horse was spooked by illegal fireworks — an enforcement failure, not a carriage safety failure. “Those two particular horses have been around fireworks, but if we can’t prepare for the fireworks, we can’t make sure the horses are prepared for the fireworks,” she said.
“An illegal firework behind a set of horses, that isn’t our fault. That is enforcement.” Pluckebaum echoed the sentiment: “Humans get spooked too. You throw fireworks at my car and I might hit the brakes or do something silly too.”
Residents are split. East Sacramento Neighborhood Association President Dimitry Saras said members haven’t voiced concern about the carriages themselves, but traffic mitigation is critical. “We hear again and again from neighbors that, with the traffic being so bad, they can’t leave their driveway between the hours of like 4:00 p.m. and 10:00 p.m. a lot of times between Thanksgiving and Christmas,” Saras told CapRadio.
Resident Paul Helliker questioned why carriages were singled out: “There are walkers, there are thousands of cars and trucks. There are now more recently pedicabs frequenting the streets there and carrying people around. Traffic moves slower than those horse-drawn carriages.”
A group of neighbors in the holiday zone pushed back in a press release obtained by KCRA 3: “The fundamental problem is that horses are living animals with natural instincts that cannot be eliminated through regulation. A city can license drivers, inspect wagons, establish operating rules, and require veterinary certifications. But it cannot regulate a horse’s instinctive flight response when frightened or threatened.”

Pluckebaum is now racing to assemble a traffic management plan by early December, relying on volunteers and cones rather than paid staff. “The cost to staff and traffic management is prohibitively expensive, tens of thousands of dollars,” he said. “The more the community wants to engage, the more we can make this a tradition that works for everyone.”
He acknowledged the divide: “The real issue, from my point of view overall, is the traffic. Just trying to manage traffic and make sure that folks that are coming through are doing that in a respectful and kind of, you know, neighborly kind of way.”
The episode mirrors a broader national tension. New York City banned horse-drawn carriages earlier this year after an 18-year-old tourist was thrown and killed in Central Park; that law takes effect June 1, 2028.
Sacramento’s aborted ordinance would have required a two-thirds council vote to take immediate effect. For now, the carriages roll on — and the city has until next holiday season to decide whether the Fab 40s can accommodate both the traffic and the tradition.
