The Salem Fraternal Order of Eagles will serve fried muskrat to exactly 100 ticket holders on Jan. 30, continuing a South Jersey tradition now in its 50th year. Just 100 tickets will be sold at $40 apiece for a plate that comes with pepper cabbage, potato salad, green beans and dessert, NJ.com reported.
Social time runs from 3 to 5 p.m. at the club on East Broadway, and dinner is served at 5 p.m. A second dinner is set for March 13. The March 2026 dinner was listed as sold out. Preparation begins long before the dinner. Before anyone in Salem sits down to a plate, the animals are skinned, gutted and soaked, then parted out, soaked again and frozen. The day before the dinner they are thawed and parboiled with seasoning. Only then are they fried. Trappers made far more money selling pelts and sold the meat on the side. Fewer muskrats are being trapped. The dinners have been harder to sustain. The number of groups holding wild game dinners continues to dwindle.
The dinner returned, and the fire company expected about 225 people in 2023. The Salem Fire Department and the VFW post in Elsinboro also held dinners that year. Contrary to the common assumption, it doesn’t taste like chicken. John Zander, whose family runs Zander Fur in West Deptford, compared it to oysters.
Kyle Fisher, who organized the Lower Alloways Creek dinner in 2023, said duck is the closest match. Tickets must be paid for in advance by Tuesday, Jan. 26. Call the club at 856-935-2357 after 4 p.m. Tuesday through Friday, or between 1 and 5 p.m. Saturday and Sunday. Tickets can also be paid for in cash at the club or by Venmo or Cash App.