Sen. Ron Johnson walked back comments he made Wednesday suggesting Social Security should be shut down, calling his own language “imprecise” after Democratic colleagues and advocacy groups seized on the remarks.
The Wisconsin Republican, who chairs the Senate Budget Committee, appeared on Fox Business ahead of a committee hearing and declared the program a “legal Ponzi scheme” that cannot be fixed.
“You just shut it down and hope that you can recover some of your money,” Johnson said, adding that the government can “force investors to keep putting money into it.” The comments came the same day he released a chairman’s memo titled “Social Security: The Reality… a Legal Ponzi Scheme,” WPR reported.
The backlash was immediate. Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon, the panel’s top Democrat, said it was the first time in decades a Budget Committee chairman had suggested shuttering the program rather than repairing it.
“In effect, saying he would rather throw in the towel than have billionaires pay their fair share,” Wyden told the committee. Sen. Ben Ray Luján of New Mexico added that if the Republican position is that Social Security cannot be fixed, “there’s a problem.”

“I was talking about Ponzi schemes — you can’t fix them. Imprecise statement, I’ll admit, but everything I’ve written, everything I’ve said, clearly, I am not proposing shutting down Social Security.”
— Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wis., during the Budget Committee hearing
Johnson repeated the clarification twice during the hearing, insisting his Fox Business comments referred to the mechanics of Ponzi schemes generally, not a policy prescription for Social Security. His memo ultimately calls for Congress to repeal the provision that would trigger automatic benefit cuts when the trust fund is depleted — currently projected for 2032, according to Social Security Administration trustees — and then address the broader federal debt.
The trust fund deadline driving the debate
The 2032 depletion date is not new, but it sharpens the stakes. Nearly 1.4 million Wisconsin residents collect benefits, according to the latest government statistics. Once reserves run dry, the program can pay only about 77% of scheduled benefits from ongoing payroll tax revenue — an automatic cut Johnson’s memo says Congress should repeal to “quit scaring seniors.”
Democrats argue the shortfall is solvable by raising or eliminating the payroll tax cap. In 2026, wages above $184,500 are not subject to the Social Security tax, while Medicare taxes apply to all earnings.
Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Moreno, in a New York Times opinion piece, called lifting the cap a “no-brainer” that would ask the wealthiest Americans to contribute the same share of income as a factory worker in Chillicothe, Ohio, or a teacher in Worcester, Mass.
Ron Johnson: "At this point, there's really no way to fix Social Security. It's a Ponzi scheme. You can't fix it, you just shut it down and hope that you can recovery some of your money." pic.twitter.com/H64L1gnCvr
Johnson defends calling Social Security a Ponzi scheme
Johnson has labeled Social Security a “legal Ponzi scheme” for years, a framing Richard Fiesta, executive director of the Alliance for Retired Americans, rejected Wednesday. “It’s disappointing that the Chair of the Senate Budget Committee is more interested in making inflammatory remarks on television designed to scare older Americans than discussing common sense ways to strengthen Social Security,” Fiesta said in a statement provided to WPR.
WisPolitics noted Johnson acknowledged becoming a “lightning rod” but said the provocation was deliberate. “Otherwise, we’ve had hearing after hearing, nobody pays attention,” he told the committee. “Maybe now the American people pay attention. If I’ve got to pay a political price for that, that’s fine. I really don’t care. I’d rather go home.”
What the memo actually proposes
Despite the “shut it down” soundbite, the chairman’s report does not call for ending the program. It urges repealing the statutory benefit reduction tied to trust fund exhaustion and then pivoting to deficit reduction. Johnson does not support raising the taxable earnings cap, a position Merkley pressed him on during the hearing, according to WisPolitics.
Before entering politics, Ron Johnson built a plastics manufacturing company in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, serving as its chief executive for more than two decades. He first won election to the Senate in 2010 by defeating incumbent Russ Feingold, then won rematches against Feingold in 2016 and against Mandela Barnes in 2022.
As a freshman senator he gained attention for stalling or voting against budget proposals from both parties that he said lacked spending offsets, establishing a record of fiscal confrontation that later led to his chairmanship of the Budget Committee.
The hearing itself — streamed on the Budget Committee website — was billed as an examination of the program’s finances. Johnson’s memo cites the 2026 trustees report showing the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance trust fund exhausting reserves in 2032, a year earlier than the 2025 report projected.