Shasta Supervisors Vote to Put Flock Camera Ban on Ballot After Public Outcry

District 1 Supervisor Kevin Crye, who voted for the five-year, $551,000 contract with Flock Group Inc. last year, told the board he had made a mistake and that protecting constitutional rights must be “bulletproof,” according to thecalifornian.com. Crye said, “Here is the thing about life and if you do get a second chance, it’s important to make things right.” The Nov. 17 vote was 4-0.

Sheriff offers policy changes, cites investigative value

Sheriff Michael Johnson defended the cameras as a “force multiplier” that helps solve crimes and locate missing persons, and said he would be the first to remove them if courts find them unconstitutional, Jefferson Public Radio reported. Johnson offered to strengthen privacy safeguards, including requiring allied agencies to sign memoranda of understanding with detailed reasons for data access and providing any policy changes to supervisors before implementation, thecalifornian.com reported.

Lt. Kody Bodner said the cameras do not use facial recognition, do not sell data, and do not capture names, birthdates, Social Security numbers, addresses or driver identities, according to thecalifornian.com.

“I got educated on a lot of things and had a chance to look at our internal system and see that we do have the ability to tighten some things up and to maintain the integrity of that system,” Johnson said.

Funding and contract details

The city of Shasta Lake operates two additional Flock cameras under a separate agreement, Jefferson Public Radio reported.

Activists push for immediate removal

“You should have seen [the problems] and realized the faults in what you were doing before we brought it to your attention, not after the fact,” one commenter told the board, according to shastascout.org.

Supervisor Corkey Harmon said he did not want the responsibility of deciding whether a loved one goes unprotected without the cameras, shastascout.org reported. “Do I want to be responsible for your loved one not being protected?” Supervisor Corkey Harmon asked during today’s county board meeting.

Over 40 speakers address board for three hours

Inside, more than 40 speakers addressed the board during an agenda item that lasted over three hours, shastascout.org reported. Supervisor Matt Plummer counted 33 speakers opposed to the cameras and only eight in support.

One commenter told supervisors they should have recognized faults in the program before the public brought them forward, shastascout.org reported. Since September, residents have organized through groups such as Flock Off Shasta County to push for removal of the 24 cameras installed last year, according to shastascout.org.

Supervisors avoid direct vote, seek ballot measure

Triggered by Crye’s motion, the board directed County Counsel Joseph Larmour to return with information on a ballot measure that would amend the county charter to prohibit the Flock-type surveillance used by the sheriff’s office, thecalifornian.com reported. The Nov. 17 vote was 4-0, with District 2 Supervisor Allen Long, a retired Redding police lieutenant, absent, thecalifornian.com noted.

Supervisor Corkey Harmon said he did not want the responsibility of deciding whether a loved one goes unprotected without the cameras, shastascout.org reported. “Do I want to be responsible for your loved one not being protected? I don’t want that responsibility,” Harmon said after the lengthy public comment session. Both votes left activists mostly disappointed, according to shastascout.org.

County Counsel to present findings Dec. 8

County Counsel will present findings on the ballot measure process at the board’s Dec. 8 meeting, thecalifornian.com reported. Supervisors also requested the sheriff’s office return with a presentation on potential policy updates, Jefferson Public Radio reported.