Siena Survey: 70% of NYers Say High Utility Costs Hurt Finances

New York utility bills now cost much more than before.

More than 70% of New Yorkers surveyed by Siena University said high utility costs hurt their finances, according to reporting from Spectrum News.

This cost escalation is happening faster here than the national trend, as Joshua Macey, a professor at Yale Law School who studies energy policy, noted when citing data from the U.S. Energy Information Administration.

“Between August 2019 and August 2026, the residential price rose almost 56%, while the national price rose 36 and a half percent,” said Macey.

For a single-family home in New York City, the average energy bill runs $218 monthly, up from about $144 pre-pandemic, according to Con Edison data.

Upstate residents see even steeper increases; single-family households there spend $147 monthly, compared to just $71 in 2019, as detailed by New York State Electric and Gas data.

These rising costs stem from three factors: high infrastructure expenses nationwide, increasing energy commodity prices, and specific energy policies affecting the bills, Macey explained.

Kevin Lanahan, senior vice president for external affairs at the New York Independent System Operator, said that the system faces less supply against rising consumer demand, driving up the cost of that commodity.

The state’s policy focus, avoiding coal energy, led to stricter emissions rules for aging power plants, which either had to upgrade or stop producing electricity, Lanahan described.

A major shift hit city residents in 2017 when then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo brokered the shutdown of the Indian Point nuclear power plant in Westchester citing environmental concerns.

Effective in 2021, that closure removed 25% of all electric power consumed by New York City, a vacuum later filled by fossil fuel sources, Macey observed.

Siena Survey: 70% of NYers Say High Utility Costs Hurt Finances
Photo: nystateofpolitics.com

“[The state] was not building new infrastructure while resources were retiring,” said Macey.

While New York has drawn solar and wind projects, critics point to high costs and reliance on taxpayer subsidies, such as during a recent debate over tax breaks for a new wind turbine project in Madison County.

Gov. Kathy Hochul has eased some state mandates, pushing back on strict green energy goals and approving the long-stalled natural gas Northeast Supply Enhancement Pipeline connecting New York to Pennsylvania.

Constellation, an energy company, highlighted the benefit of nuclear power, noting that the United States has benefited from a whole lot of nuclear power generation without pollution, Mark Rodgers of the energy company Constellation said.

“Yes, this plant may have been first turned on in 1988, but because of all the maintenance that we’ve done since then and improvements, that it actually runs better today than it did then,” said Rodgers.

Constellation operates three upstate sites, employing about two thousand people and supporting thousands more in construction and service industry jobs, though they rely on a state subsidy of about $400 million a year, extended through 2049, the company reported.

The challenge facing new nuclear development is the long timeline and expense; Rodgers explained that getting the necessary public-private interactions right requires many parties working together.

NYISO’s current focus remains ensuring reliable power twenty-four seven, as they face significant reliability deficiencies starting in 2032 or 2033, Lanahan warned.

U.S. Energy Information Administration data tracks national price changes.

nystateofpolitics.com reported on the Siena University survey findings.

New York Independent System Operator manages consumer demand and dispatches energy.

Constellation says keeping operations running saves customers money in the long run, though critics argue this locks in high costs already among the nation’s highest.