Southern New Hampshire University dominated every statistical category Friday afternoon in Charleston, West Virginia, and still saw its season end on penalty kicks.
The eighth-ranked Penmen outshot Davis & Elkins 3-0 on target and held a 7-1 advantage in corner kicks across 110 scoreless minutes at Welch Athletic Complex, yet fell 7-6 in the shootout after the Senators missed their first two attempts and converted seven straight, Southern New Hampshire University reported.
The loss caps a season in which SNHU went unbeaten in 19 of 20 matches, including a 13-shutout campaign that fell two clean sheets short of the program record. Garcia, a Barcelona native in his second year with the program, finishes his Penmen career with 18 shutouts and a current scoreless streak of 328:57.
Southern New Hampshire entered the third round having blanked St. Thomas Aquinas 3-0 on November 15 at Ouellette Stadium in Hooksett, a result GSM GlobalNews noted pushed the Penmen to 14-1-4 at the time. Senior forward Inigo Iriarte broke that deadlock in the 56th minute, and Garcia made four saves to preserve the clean sheet.

Against Davis & Elkins, the Penmen’s best opportunity arrived in the 76th minute when freshman Dani Bujanda served a corner to fellow Spaniard Inigo Burusco, whose header sailed just over the crossbar. SNHU led the shootout 2-1 before a missed attempt and a Senators conversion swung momentum; Davis & Elkins, ranked 11th nationally and unbeaten in 18 of 19 matches this fall, did not miss again.
The program’s larger ledger tells a different story than Friday’s result. Since the 2013 national championship season, Southern New Hampshire has compiled a 176-43-34 record (.763 winning percentage) across 253 matches. Over the last 66 games dating to 2023, that mark improves to 48-7-11 (.811). In Super Region 1 play specifically, the Penmen have not conceded a goal in 519:47 and hold an 11-0 scoring margin over their last five regional contests.
Southern New Hampshire University began in 1932 as the New Hampshire School of Accounting and Secretarial Science, founded by accountant Harry A. B. Shapiro and his wife Gertrude. It became a nonprofit college in 1968, adopted its current name in 2001, and grew from 25 students at Shapiro’s death in 1952 to 170,000 online learners and 3,000 on campus by 2021.
Davis & Elkins advances to Sunday’s quarterfinal at the same Charleston venue. Southern New Hampshire’s season ends at 14-1-5, the only blemishes a lone regular-season loss on October 17 and Friday’s shootout defeat.