St. Cecilia Punch Recipe Violates Society’s Sherry-Only Drinking Rules

St. Cecilia’s feast day brings a historic Charleston punch recipe that contradicts the secretive society’s own rules.

  • The St. Cecilia Society, founded in 1762, limited drinks to sherry or coffee-flavored punch at its exclusive Hibernian Hall balls.
  • A member leaked a potent recipe with Champagne, rum, brandies, and green tea to Helen Woodward for a 1934 cookbook update.
  • The recipe appears first in Charleston Receipts, the oldest Junior League cookbook in existence, published in 1950.

November 22 marks the feast day of St. Cecilia, the patron saint of music martyred in Rome after a forced marriage she kept chaste through divine intervention. Her namesake society in Charleston began with private concerts in 1762 but evolved, according to a 1964 New York Times story, into an annual ball for “generations of local swells” at Hibernian Hall.

“St, Cecilia’s not like Skull and Bones,” a young aristocrat told the Times. “We don’t go getting up and walk out of the room when St. Cecilia’s mentioned. We just don’t Iike to talk about it.”

The Times noted the society’s rules stipulated “no drinking except sherry or coffee‐flavored punch,” with “French Champagne” reserved for midnight supper. That formality clashes with the St. Cecilia Punch a member eventually leaked to Helen Woodward for the hard-to-find 1934 update of Two Hundred Years of Charleston Cooking.

Woodward, who wrote the introduction and notes for Blanche Rhett’s book, added a “plantation cocktails” section featuring the punch: “a concoction of lemon brandy, peach brandy, green tea, Champagne, rum, and soda,” Yahoo reported. “Is it possible that St. Cecilia punch contributes to the glamour” of the balls, Woodward pondered.

Photo: yahoo.com

By 1950 the recipe had escaped the vault entirely. It appears alongside Otranto Club Punch, Cotillion Club Punch, and Charleston Club Punch in Charleston Receipts, now the oldest Junior League cookbook in existence, where it remains the first recipe in the comb-bound volume, AOL reported.