St. Paul School Board Calls for Indefinite Pause on New Charter School Authorizations

“The reality is we’re allocating funds to the same number of schools for a dwindling number of students, and we do need to take action as a community,” board member Yusef Carrillo said before the vote Tuesday night.

The St. Paul Public Schools Board of Education unanimously approved a resolution asking the Minnesota Legislature to pause new charter school authorizations in the city indefinitely, KSTP reported. The move comes as the district conducts a broader review of buildings and programs while enrollment continues a years‑long slide.

Charter schools in St. Paul grew from serving about 1 in 13 public school students in 2001‑02 to more than 1 in 3 by 2022‑23, according to a fiscal analysis commissioned from North Star Policy Action. The number of St. Paul students attending charters rose from just over 4,000 in 2001 to more than 14,000 in 2024, while district enrollment fell by more than 12,000 over roughly the same period.

St. Paul School Board Calls for Indefinite Pause on New Charter School Authorizations
Photo: theminneapolis.org

Researchers estimated that charter growth creates between $7.2 million and $17.7 million annually in indirect costs for the district — fixed expenses like bus routes and building maintenance that don’t shrink when students leave. Charters also billed SPPS directly for about $13.6 million in special‑education and other services in the 2023‑24 fiscal year, a total exceeding $125 million since 2007‑08.

“It may be easiest to start with the conventional wisdom, which is that public schools don’t lose money if students move from a public school to a charter school. The truth is actually more complicated,”

said Aaron Rosenthal, research director for North Star Policy Action.

Rosenthal compared the dynamic to a bus route that loses one rider but still burns the same fuel. Board chair Uriah Ward framed the request as a response to simple arithmetic: 59 charter schools and 69 district schools now compete for a shrinking pool of children amid declining birth rates, reduced immigration and open‑enrollment options.

St. Paul schools wants to stop new charter schools. Here's why. — KSTP 5 Eyewitness News

Not everyone sees a moratorium as the answer. Joey Cienian, executive director of the Minnesota Association of Charter Schools, called the proposal “bad policy” that would not solve broader funding challenges. “Charter public schools are mission‑driven public schools that are free and open‑to‑all that must demonstrate community need before opening, and we believe families deserve a variety of public school options,” Cienian said.

Carrie Bakken, executive director of Avalon School in St. Paul, noted that many families split enrollment between sectors. “We have students at Avalon School who also have siblings enrolled in St. Paul Public Schools. Families are just trying to find the right fit for each of their children,” she said. Bakken argued for collaboration over restriction, suggesting partnerships could generate additional revenue for the district.

Rosenthal acknowledged a pause would not stop families from choosing existing charters, though he said data show a strong relationship between new charter openings and subsequent student movement out of district schools. The Legislature has not yet signaled whether it will take up the request when it convenes next session. Mayor Kaohly Her’s office did not respond to a request for comment.