Study: Colorado PUC Too Small for Energy Transition

Colorado’s Public Utilities Commission is too small, too thinly staffed, and too rigidly structured for the energy transition it is being asked to manage, according to the first phase of a legislative-ordered review delivered to the General Assembly this week.

The Regulatory Assistance Project, a nonprofit advisory group staffed by former commissioners and utility executives, produced the diagnosis after months of stakeholder interviews and benchmarking against peer states. Its findings center on a workforce that has not kept pace with a docket load swollen by wildfire mitigation plans, distributed energy resources, and the state’s aggressive decarbonization mandates.

“The volume and complexity of the work has fundamentally changed,” the report says, noting that the PUC’s authorized full-time equivalent count has barely moved while proceeding types have multiplied. The study identifies nine priority areas for deeper analysis in Phase 2, due in 2027, ranging from compensation structures that struggle to compete with the private sector to the mechanics of expanding the commission from three to five members.

Study: Colorado PUC Too Small for Energy Transition

Intervenors — the consumer advocates, environmental groups, and local governments that challenge utility proposals — face their own structural barriers. The report documents a compensation system that is difficult to access and legal support that is often insufficient, effectively muting voices the legislature intended to amplify.

The three-member commission model, unchanged since the agency’s creation, is a focal point. Peer states with five commissioners — including Oregon and Washington — report better deliberative capacity and continuity during turnover. But the report also flags the cost: new commissioners mean new staff, new offices, and a longer confirmations process in a Senate already stretched thin.

Competitive pay emerged as a quiet crisis. Entry-level analysts at the PUC earn much less than those at investor-owned utilities or law firms, creating a revolving door that erodes institutional memory just as cases become more technical. The Phase 1 analysis recommends a market study to reset salary bands, a step the legislature could fund as early as the 2026 session.

The Regulatory Assistance Project was founded in 1992 to help U.S. utility regulators improve energy planning and has since grown into a global, independent non-governmental organization. Its team of former commissioners and utility executives advises policymakers on every continent, drawing on decades of benchmarking and technical assistance to shape regulatory frameworks for the energy transition.

Phase 2 will convert these themes into legislative language. Until then, the PUC continues to process rate cases, clean-energy plans, and wildfire mitigation filings with the same skeleton crew the report says is structurally inadequate.