Three Vendors Suspended at Olympia Farmers Market, Exposing Governance Vacuum

Three Olympia Farmers Market vendors have been suspended or forced out since September, exposing a governance vacuum at the 50-year-old institution where neither the city nor the port claims authority over daily operations.

The latest blow fell on Nov. 7, when market director Alvinita J. Stuart issued a permanent suspension to Kevin and Stacy Box, owners of the knife-making business Crafted Restorations. The letter cited their social media posts criticizing the market — not the original display and insurance violations that prompted an Oct. 13 suspension — as the grounds for revoking their membership and accumulated seniority points, The Olympian reported.

Why were the vendors suspended?

Each case followed a different trigger. Ryan Bally, owner of Odin’s Alchemy Brewing, was permanently suspended on Sept. 25 after a customer accessed mead sampling bottles while he stepped away for a medical phone call. Bally told The Olympian his reinstatement efforts failed and he will not return, costing him the majority of his sales.

Crafted Restorations was initially suspended Oct. 13 for removing a plexiglass barrier the market required over its knife display and for lacking liability insurance. The market said the insurance requirement had been communicated to all vendors through Market Notes and that the Boxes had received an extension to comply.

But the Nov. 7 letter made clear the permanent suspension rested on their Facebook and Instagram posts, which Stuart wrote “directed the public to email the Board and the Market Director” and led to “threatening emails.”

Three Vendors Suspended at Olympia Farmers Market, Exposing Governance Vacuum
Photo: yahoo.com

In April 2026, Janna Taylor of Mother’s Roots Kitchen shut down her restaurant after being presented with a new contract that, she said, mandated she never sell out early and never close on a market day — conditions she labeled impossible to satisfy.

Who actually runs the market?

The market operates as a nonprofit on Port of Olympia land at 700 Capitol Way N., in year 30 of a 50-year lease with an option to renew for 30 more. The City of Olympia owns the buildings. The port’s 2025 rent revenue reached $145,000, up from $113,000 in 2022, because rent is tied to revenue, according to port community and economic development director Mike Reid.

City spokesman Brandon Chapman said the maintenance and operating agreement requires the market to carry at least $2 million in commercial general liability coverage per occurrence, but does not expressly require individual vendors to buy separate policies. Scott River, the city’s liaison to the market, said that requirement is probably between the board and its vendors. “The city doesn’t tell them how to run,” River said.

Both the city and the port say they have no role in day-to-day market operations or vendor discipline. The market board declined to discuss specific vendors, saying through email that because it may review appeals, “it would be inappropriate for us to express an opinion on the decision or the circumstances surrounding it.”

What changed this spring?

Alvinita J. Stuart, known as Alvi Stuart, replaced Isabel Thomas as market director in early April. Thomas had worked at the market for about four years in roles from customer service to manager.

David Coffey, a former vendor, board member and maintenance manager with 17 years at the market, said Thomas was dismissed for reasons that were not clear. He quit around the same time; other staff left too. Coffey said he applied to return as a vendor about four weeks ago and was denied.

How big is the market economically?

The market generated nearly $9.7 million in total gross sales in 2025. For vendors like Bally and the Boxes, the market represents the bulk of their revenue. Box said the market is the biggest part of his business and that he would likely need to lay off one employee if he cannot return.

Bally said he would likely need a second job. Box’s knives have since found a new outlet at Childhood’s End Gallery in downtown Olympia.

Boxes plan appeal and legal action as board stays silent

The Boxes plan to appeal through the market board’s process and are pursuing legal action, though Kevin Box declined to detail the legal strategy. The board has not commented on the merits of the suspension, citing the pending appeal. No public hearing date has been announced.

“The outpouring of the community adds to the righteousness of what I’m doing,” Kevin Box told The Olympian.

The Port of Olympia was created on November 7, 1922, when Thurston County voters authorized a port authority to develop a waterfront industrial area on Budd Inlet.

The district now holds more than 1,200 acres, including the 60-acre Marine Terminal, Olympia Airport, Swantown Marina and the Market District where the farmers market operates under a 50-year lease. By 2010 it ranked second in Washington for lumber cargo; as of 2025 it averages about 20 ship calls annually and generates nearly $2.0 million in revenue.

The market’s layered real estate arrangement — port land, city buildings, nonprofit operator — leaves no single public body overseeing vendor decisions, a gap that has drawn scrutiny as the suspensions mount.