Tony & Nick’s Steaks in South Philadelphia to Close After 35 Years

Tony & Nick’s Steaks will serve its last cheesesteak Friday, closing a South Philadelphia shop that has operated for 35 years under two names and a long-running family rift.

The owners announced the shutdown this week in a letter posted to the restaurant’s Instagram story, CBS News reported. “After 35 years in business — and even more years spent serving sandwiches together — this is one of the hardest things we have ever had to say,” the letter reads.

“Financial difficulties and tax problems have brought us to a point where we can no longer keep our doors open. It breaks my heart to write these words. We are devastated.”

The shop, owned by Anthony Lucidonio Sr. and his son Nicholas Lucidonio, reopened as Tony & Nick’s in 2022 after a name change forced by a family feud and mounting tax trouble.

The original brand, Tony Luke’s, remains a separate franchise run by Lucidonio Sr.’s other son, Tony Luke Jr., who split from his father and brother in 2015. That franchise operates locations in several states and has no connection to the closing shop, according to its website.

Tony & Nick's Steaks in South Philadelphia closes for good — CBS Philadelphia

The financial problems cited in the farewell letter crystallized in 2024, when both Lucidonio Sr. and Nicholas Lucidonio were sentenced to 20 months in federal prison. They had pleaded guilty to hiding nearly $8 million in sales over a decade, paying employees partly off the books and keeping separate ledgers to conceal revenue, according to federal prosecutors.

“We wish this chapter had a different ending,” the owners wrote. “Please know how grateful we are for the years you gave us and for allowing our family to be part of your lives.”

Tony & Nick's Steaks in South Philadelphia to Close After 35 Years

Tony & Nick’s Catering will continue operating, the letter said.