Trenton voters will decide the city’s next mayor in a Dec. 8 runoff between challenger Corey McNair and incumbent Reed Gusciora after McNair surged to a commanding first-place finish in the Nov. 3 general election.
McNair captured 4,417 votes (34.12%) in a six-candidate field, leading Gusciora by more than 1,650 votes. The mayor finished with 2,767 votes (23.25%), a sharp drop from the 5,792 votes he collected in his 2022 re-election and the 4,500 that first put him in office in 2018.
“They also had a first-hand view of how the candidates responded and interacted with the public,” Irwin Stoolmacher, president of the Stoolmacher Consulting Group, wrote in his column, arguing the four eliminated candidates — who together drew 43% of the vote — should weigh an endorsement based on who gives Trenton the best chance for transformation.

Gusciora has called for four debates before Election Day. McNair has declined, saying he would rather spend time face to face with residents in neighborhoods. Stoolmacher urged McNair to accept at least one well-publicized, moderated debate, noting the recent $4.7 million jury award to former Police Director Sheilah A. Coley in a wrongful-termination and whistleblower suit against the city.
Coley verdict highlights police department issues
Coley testified she was fired for resisting political pressure to give preferential treatment to two white officers who allegedly lied about residency on applications and to shut down an internal-affairs investigation. The verdict, delivered weeks before the runoff, puts the administration’s handling of the police department at center stage.
Trenton Mayor Reed Gusciora faces challenger Corey McNair in a runoff election slated for early December. via @DavidMatthau https://t.co/UDgu1xZeEF
Stoolmacher also pointed to allegations that the city engaged in “contract splitting” on the $195,000 deforestation of Stacy Park — breaking a large project into smaller invoices to circumvent public-bidding laws. Unless an extreme emergency exists, he wrote, those laws should be stringently followed.
Gusciora has rebounded from a first-round deficit before
History offers the incumbent a template. In June 2018, Gusciora won his first mayoral election against Paul Perez after finishing second in the general election that spring. He enters the runoff with a large campaign fund and three decades of political experience.
He authored the Paramount Safety Law, which changed the state’s child-custody standard to protect children when abuse has occurred, and sponsored the New Jersey Smoke-Free Air Act that banned smoking in indoor public places and workplaces.
In 2012 his floor remarks comparing Governor Chris Christie to segregation-era governors drew national attention. After legislative redistricting moved his Princeton home into a Republican-leaning district, Gusciora put the house on the market and moved to Trenton, the city he had long represented, to remain eligible for office.
The four trailing candidates — Austin Edwards (1,709 votes, 14.36%), Jasi Edwards (1,480 votes, 12.44%), Rolando Ramos (1,191 votes, 10.01%) and Edward Forchion (299 votes, 2.51%) — have not yet announced endorsements.