The Broadway musical “Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)” will close at the Longacre Theatre on November 29 and reopen Off-Broadway at New World Stages on March 22, 2027, with an official opening night set for April 4, 2027, TheaterMania reported.
The Tony-nominated production announced the transfer at the curtain call of its Friday performance, Deadline reported. The move shifts the show one avenue west to New World Stages at 340 West 50th Street, just a few blocks from its current Broadway home.
Cast will not transfer
Current Broadway stars Sam Tutty and Christiani Pitts are not expected to move with the production, Deadline reported. New casting for the Off-Broadway engagement has not been announced. The pair originated the roles of Dougal, an optimistic Brit arriving for his estranged father’s wedding, and Robin, the bride’s pragmatic sister, since the show’s Broadway opening on November 20, 2025.

Creative team and production details
The musical features a book and score by Jim Barne and Kit Buchan, with direction and choreography by Tim Jackson. The Off-Broadway production will retain the Broadway design team: scenic and costume design by Soutra Gilmour, lighting by Jack Knowles, sound by Tony Gayle, orchestrations by Lux Pyramid, and music supervision by Nick Finlow, according to Deadline and Broadway.com.
North American tour launching fall 2027
A North American tour is scheduled to launch in fall 2027, Broadway.com reported.
Plot and Character Details
Robin is identified as the sister of the bride, a no-nonsense New Yorker tasked with errands that include picking up the groom’s estranged son from the airport. The two strangers begin their journey together moving through the city, secrets, and second chances, according to TheaterMania.

Broadway.com adds that the bride’s guarded sister, Robin, picks Dougal up at JFK before they go off to collect the wedding cake. The outlet notes that romantic, comedic, and musical delights ensue from that premise.
North American tour launching fall 2027
A North American tour is scheduled to launch in fall 2027, Broadway.com reported.
Awards and reception
The production earned eight 2026 Tony Award nominations, including Best Musical, and a 2026 Grammy Award nomination. It won three 2026 Broadway.com Audience Choice Awards: Favorite Funny Performance, Favorite Onstage Pair, and Favorite Original Song for “New York,” Broadway.com reported.
The Boston Globe called it “IRRESISTIBLE! Clever, funny, and delightfully surprising!” TheaterMania reported.
The show premiered at London’s Kiln Theatre in November 2023 before transferring to the West End’s Criterion Theatre in 2024, Broadway.com reported.