In a column for the Hawaii Tribune-Herald, University of Hawaii at Hilo Chancellor Bonnie D. Irwin argues that the sheer volume of digital photos has eroded their value compared with the scarcity of physical prints.
Irwin writes that a recent delivery of century-old family photos — formal, unsmiling portraits in uncomfortable clothes — felt more precious than the hundreds of images on her phone. “They are precious because they contain history, our history, even if we do not know which part of our history it is,” she writes.
The shift from film to digital removed limits on how many photos one could take, and smartphones made cameras constant companions, she writes. Irwin describes taking a dozen shots at a Vulcan basketball game, posting two, and leaving the rest until a “photo clean out” — the modern equivalent of shoeboxes left unorganized until someone moves or dies.
“By sheer numbers, however, it would be a lot more shoeboxes!” she writes. “Oh, wait a minute, I think it was last May,” she writes, which helps scroll through to the right place. She finds that dozens of these snaps quickly accumulate on her phone.
Cloud storage has become “one gigantic shoebox filled with random photos of random people in random places” where abundance makes images lose their specialness, she writes. Another difference: people in selfies are mostly smiling, capturing experiences rather than just faces. “Through the selfie, our memories are more visual than verbal,” she writes. “What we might have once jotted down in a letter or diary is now captured on our phones.”
Irwin writes that photographic technology has changed behavior, and regenerative AI is accelerating the shift. At UH Hilo, degree concentrations have been developed to help students understand and use the new technology because employers expect those skills. “We have to keep up,” she writes. “Not just photos are at our fingertips but billions of words, images, and sounds, all of which can now be sorted at the speed of light.”
Chancellor Bonnie D. Irwin, leading the University of Hawai‘i at Hilo since July 1, 2019, brings a background as provost and vice president for academic affairs at CSU Monterey Bay and dean of the College of Arts and Humanities at Eastern Illinois University.
A scholar of oral traditions and folklore with a Ph.D. in comparative literature from UC Berkeley, she frames the digital photo deluge as a cultural shift where abundance erodes meaning, contrasting today’s “gigantic shoebox” of cloud images with the precious scarcity of century-old prints.
Her leadership priority emerges in the curriculum response: UH Hilo has developed degree concentrations so students can understand and use generative AI because employers expect those skills. “We have to keep up,” she writes, linking technological velocity to workforce readiness.
AI will eliminate the weeks once spent sorting old photos, she writes, but she hopes the saved time is used for something worthwhile. “Stopping to think and remember and share an experience must still be part of who we are,” she writes. “It’s okay if technology speeds up the sorting process, but my hope for us all is that we use that “found time” for something worthwhile,” she writes.