UNC Center Cameron Fens Files Lawsuit Seeking Sixth NCAA Season

North Carolina center Cameron Fens filed a lawsuit Wednesday in Orange County Superior Court asking a judge to grant him a sixth season of eligibility, arguing a misdiagnosed stress fracture at South Dakota cost him a year he should have been able to redshirt, WRAL reported.

The complaint seeks a temporary restraining order that would let the 7-foot center suit up for the Tar Heels as early as Friday’s game against Marshall while the case moves forward. A hearing is set for Thursday at 11 a.m.

The injury and the waiver denial

Fens felt pain in his right foot in November 2024 during his third college season at South Dakota, according to the complaint cited by the Associated Press in reports carried by MRT and Yahoo Sports.

Team medical staff diagnosed a soft-tissue injury without ordering imaging, the filing says, and Fens kept practicing and playing until he aggravated the injury on Jan. 16, 2025. A surgeon later found evidence the bone had been healing from a stress fracture and that the second injury “was a progression” of the first.

UNC Center Cameron Fens Files Lawsuit Seeking Sixth NCAA Season
Photo: thespec.com

Because Fens had appeared in more than 30 percent of South Dakota’s games, NCAA guidelines allow a hardship waiver only for extraordinary circumstances such as medical misdiagnosis. South Dakota applied for that waiver in February; the NCAA denied it on Oct. 20, saying Fens had been medically cleared to compete at his original school, the AP reported.

A crowded field of fifth-year lawsuits

Fens is part of a wave of athletes from the high-school class of 2022 who have sued the NCAA after the association adopted a five-year eligibility window that does not apply retroactively to their cohort. UNC kicker Rece Verhoff, three members of the women’s field hockey team and former Tar Heels guard Seth Trimble — now at Louisville — have all won additional seasons through court orders, according to WRAL.

“I understand that each of these players is competing under a court order,” UNC coach Michael Malone said in an affidavit filed with the court. “Playing Cameron would put him on the same footing as the fifth-year players we will compete against.”

Malone also listed NC State’s Ven-Allen Lubin, West Virginia’s Brenen Lorient and Javan Buchanan, Syracuse’s Amarri Monroe, Wake Forest’s Justin Abson and Miami’s Malik Renau as fifth-year opponents UNC will face this season.

UNC Center Cameron Fens Files Lawsuit Seeking Sixth NCAA Season
Photo: mrt.com

Fens averaged 14.4 points and 8.7 rebounds for South Dakota last season. “He is physical and strong, and he is a skilled player,” Malone wrote. “If he were eligible, he would be a regular part of our rotation.”

The NCAA, the only named defendant, did not immediately respond to requests for comment from WRAL or the Associated Press.