Utah and UCLA enter Week 12 as the last unbeaten teams in college football, both 10-0 and sitting at No. 2 and No. 4 in the College Football Playoff rankings, yet neither is favored by more than a touchdown on the road this weekend.
The Utes visit TCU as 6.5-point favorites, while the Bruins head to Ann Arbor as just 3.5-point favorites over a 5-5 Michigan team that ranks last nationally in total offense and scoring, CBS Sports reported. A half-dozen opposing coaches who faced both teams told The Athletic they respect the records but harbor serious doubts about either squad’s ability to win multiple playoff games.
The Indiana comparison haunts UCLA
Multiple Big Ten defensive coordinators compared these Bruins to the 2024 Indiana Hoosiers — Curt Cignetti’s first-year team that started 10-0 before losing at Ohio State and then falling to Notre Dame in the first round of the playoff.
“I don’t think they will win games in the Playoff,” one Big Ten defensive coordinator said. “I think why they’d struggle in the Playoff is that I don’t think they have good depth. Their O-line is solid but not elite in certain areas.”
That coordinator watched Purdue score 38 points in a 52-38 UCLA win, then saw the Bruins beat Oregon 17-15. “They play very complementary football,” he said. “But I think the one thing lacking is a couple of years of recruiting.”

A second Big Ten defensive coordinator credited how well-coached the Bruins are. “In an era where it feels like because there’s so much movement, a lot of teams just don’t play well together,” he said. “These guys play really well together. … I think Notre Dame is better than them, and on film, watching Oregon now that they’re rolling, I think if they played Oregon again, Oregon would beat them.”
UCLA leads the Big Ten with 12 rushes of 30-plus yards and eight pass plays of 50-plus yards; last season the Bruins had one such pass play. “They ran a lot of zone but also ran a lot of gap-scheme,” the second coordinator said.
“They do a good job with flavor-of-the-week with whatever gives you problems. Indiana was simpler to defend. UCLA has a bit more variety. I think they can win a game in the Playoff, but I don’t think they can go and beat some of the higher-end talent teams.”
Quarterback change sparked the Bruins
An assistant coach who played UCLA said the Bruins are better with backup Ty Dieffenbach, a Cal Poly transfer, than they were with former five-star recruit Nico Iamaleava, who suffered a season-ending injury at Oregon on Oct. 10. “He’s a better fit for this offense than Nico,” the coach said.
Dieffenbach has an 8-to-3 touchdown-to-interception ratio compared to Iamaleava’s 4-to-4. “He throws it on time. He understands anticipation of windows. He’s different from Nico, who would wait for it to get open and then try to gun it in there. This guy is good,” Bruins said.

That coach sees a path for a deep run. “Defensively, they’re sound. They’re freaking salty. Play really hard. Always in the right spot. It helps that they have like nine seniors starting on defense. They’re real seasoned on defense. They tackle well. They don’t panic. They’re physical. (Linebacker Sammy) Omosigho, I think he’s a legit All-American linebacker. He’s freaking good. He’s twitchy, explosive, can go speed to power, can run you down,” coach said.
The Bruins lead the country in takeaways (30) and interceptions (20). “I think it’ll really depend on the draw,” the coach said.
“They are so well-coached and have a culture-built system. Their special teams are good. They don’t hurt themselves. Don’t get a lot of penalties. Don’t turn the ball over. But they’ll probably have a hard time with an explosive offense that can put up a lot of points. I think it’d be tough for them to beat Miami. I don’t know if their offense can keep up.”
Utah’s unorthodox offense and a defensive tackle named Moe
Three coaches said the Utes could win a playoff game but were skeptical they could advance further. “What they do offensively is unique enough that they could win games,” an offensive line coach said.
“Their defensive front is not the same as SEC fronts, but what they do is, they play really freakin’ hard. That’s won them a bunch of games, and can it win them a Playoff game? I think it could.”
Morgan Scalley replaced Kyle Whittingham, who left for Michigan and took offensive coordinator Jason Beck, the nation’s highest-paid assistant before his firing earlier this month, along with top pass rusher John Henry Daley, top receiver JJ Buchanan, and top corner Smith Snowden. Scalley hired Kevin McGiven from Utah State, who blended run-and-shoot concepts, RPOs, and triple-option elements.
“There’s a lot of stuff they do that you just don’t see much of, but the way they operate and execute with all of that different stuff going on is pretty damn impressive, because they don’t make a lot of mistakes,” a Big 12 defensive coach said.
“It’s hard to get ready for them in a week because they do so much stuff. You gotta understand when certain guys are in the game, they’re doing certain things and attached to certain personnel groupings. You really gotta know who’s in the game when.”
San Jose State transfer Jireh Moe, an undersized defensive tackle, has replaced Daley as the player opponents circle. “He’s a 5-11 kid, but he’s got a nasty spin move,” the offensive line coach said. “He’s a really, really good player.” The Big 12 quarterbacks coach agreed: “He is the problem guy. He’s strong, stout, very quick. Just hard to block. He’s one of the best D-tackles we’ve played this year.”
Dampier dominates rushing but struggles passing
Quarterback Devon Dampier has rushed for 582 yards and nine touchdowns, with 384 yards and six scores coming in the last four games as competition stiffened. “He’s an NFL running back talent,” a Big 12 defensive coach said. “He’s faster than you think he is. A lot of his throws are into the boundary. He’s shorter, so you can bat down a lot of his passes. You just wanna keep him in the pocket and force him to throw, where he’s not as good. But he can run around and give you a lot of problems.” Dampier has thrown 22 touchdowns and eight interceptions while completing 66.5 percent of his passes. “He’s OK as a passer,” the defensive coach said.
“I think he’ll be a running back in the NFL. We ran some mesh charges that forced him to hand it off, and we rushed four and collapsed the pocket where he couldn’t get out. They’re so unorthodox offensively. They’re kind of feast or famine as an offense. You’ll stop em, stop em, stop em, and then they’ll pop a big play on you because of the gimmicky things they do. They’ll pop a run or hit a reverse pass or something like that. Nobody uses two quarterbacks that much. I don’t think they’re great up front, but they play decent as a unit. If they have to throw the ball, they’re not gonna beat you.”
Utah’s red-zone defense has been elite. Over the past month, BYU, Cincinnati, and Houston — three of the Big 12’s better offenses — scored just three touchdowns in 11 trips inside the 20. Only Arizona quarterback Noah Fifita lit up the defense. “It’s just constant pressure,” the quarterbacks coach said.
“You have to make tight-window throws, and you gotta be protected, accurate. You gotta have some checks — are they going 7-up; are they going 8-up? Are they bailing? Is it cover zero? There’s a lot of different stuff you have to do against Utah throughout the week that you don’t have to do against other teams. They do a good job of mixing it up.”
Week 12 trap games across the board
Michigan’s offensive futility — 300.9 yards per game (131st nationally), 18.3 points per game (131st), minus-10 turnover margin (134th) — makes the 3.5-point line on UCLA “terrify” Bruins fans, CBS Sports noted.
Utah and UCLA both need to survive Saturday to reach conference championship weekend with perfect records intact. The coaches who’ve seen them up close believe one playoff win is possible for either. A second win? That’s where the skepticism hardens.