Violet: Foulkes Inherits Superman Building; Developer Seeks $200M Federal Loan

Providence, R.I. — The Superman Building at 111 Westminster Street has sat vacant since 2013, a 26-story landmark that former Rhode Island Attorney General Arlene Violet says has become the “poster child for a failed downtown.”

Governor-elect Helena Foulkes inherits the long-stalled redevelopment on her first day in office, with the project’s developer, High Rock Westminster Street, seeking a federal construction loan that could reach $200 million.

Violet, writing in GoLocalProv, argued that High Rock has “manipulated the process of restoration to squeeze more money out of federal, state, and city coffers.” She noted the developer recouped its initial investment through decades of rent from Fleet Bank, later Bank of America, and collected millions from a $54 million lawsuit settlement with the bank over building deterioration.

“High Rock laughed all the way to the bank without any adjudication as to who was to blame,” Violet wrote. She added that the developer then allowed deterioration to continue, reducing the building's value to a "de minimis amount" to avoid real estate taxes.

The project already carries about $110 million in “actual cash, subsidies, and tax remission,” according to Violet. She warned that the developer is now seeking a $164 million federal construction loan, which “will probably grow to two hundred million dollars since construction costs have skyrocketed during the delays.”

Violet urged that “no taxpayer money should flow until the project is concluded and with a contract that provides for profit sharing in its operation or sale.”

Shermy and violet dressed as superman and lois by fullview

She drew a parallel to the Providence Place Mall deal, where developer Dan Lugosch received large subsidies and tax breaks, later selling the mall for $522 million while “the city and state leaders saw nary a penny.” Lugosch also successfully sued the state to recoup a $2 million conveyor tax. “Do the term sheets with High Rock have the same loopholes for the developer if they flip the property?” Violet asked.

The affordable housing component has also shrunk, Violet wrote. The original proposal included 58 units, or 20% affordable housing, but that has “metamorphosed into no more than 10%.” She predicted the percentage “will drop lower and may disappear since the amount of rent necessary to pay off its refurbishment would shrink lower-income housing availability.”

Foulkes, born in Providence in 1964, graduated magna cum laude from Harvard College in 1986 and earned an MBA from Harvard Business School. She spent 26 years at CVS Pharmacy, rising to chief marketing officer and overseeing the launch of the ExtraCare loyalty program and the decision to end tobacco sales.

She then served as CEO of Hudson’s Bay Company from February 2018 until March 2020, when the company was taken private. After losing the 2022 Democratic primary for governor to incumbent Dan McKee by fewer than 3,900 votes, she defeated him in a landslide in 2026, becoming the first person to unseat an elected incumbent governor in Rhode Island since 2014.

Violet: Foulkes Inherits Superman Building; Developer Seeks $200M Federal Loan

Robert McMahon, the former Director of Parks, proposed an alternative use.