A Wexford father was fined €200 at Wexford District Court after threatening to kill a security guard and burn down his house following an altercation involving his son on July 17, 2024, the Irish Independent reported.
David Murphy, 39, of 11 Bernadettes Avenue, Glenbrien, near Enniscorthy, appeared before Judge John Cheatle alongside his 20-year-old son, Barry Murphy. The court proceedings stemmed from an incident at the Ferrycarrig Hotel where Barry was attending his debs night.
According to evidence presented in court, Barry became involved in an altercation with a member of the hotel’s security team. As the young man headed through the car park toward the main road, his girlfriend approached a security worker to express concern that Barry had stated he was going to take his own life.
The security worker followed Barry and attempted to prevent him from leaving the car park. The court heard that Barry then kicked the worker in the stomach. Two additional security staff members intervened, with one testifying that he and a colleague restrained Barry to stop him from lashing out further.
Jeff Power, the duty manager at the Ferrycarrig Hotel, corroborated the security team’s account. Mr Power said that he arrived at the car park to find two security workers struggling to restrain Barry, who eventually agreed to stop swinging at people if allowed to get up from the ground.
Donna Kelly BL, counsel for David Murphy, argued that her client arrived to find his son, who is of slight build, being held down by two well-built security guards and would naturally have been upset by the sight. Ms Kelly highlighted that no CCTV footage covered the specific area where the initial incident occurred and that no members of the public witnessed it, which she argued should establish reasonable doubt.
Photographs presented to Judge Cheatle showed injuries sustained by Barry during the restraint, including an injury to the side of his head and bruising around his eye socket.
Barry pleaded guilty to assaulting a member of the security team under Section 2 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act. A letter of apology was presented and given to the injured party, who expressed satisfaction with its contents, leading Judge Cheatle to strike out the assault charge.
Regarding the case against David Murphy, a security worker testified that the father arrived irate and looking for a fight, threatening to kill him and burn down his house. The worker alleged he later received further threatening messages from David via Facebook. Ms Kelly put it to the witness that there was prior animosity between them and referenced a previously unprosecuted allegation made against David by the same worker.
In a voluntary cautioned statement, David Murphy denied making any threats and maintained that his sole concern was for his son’s welfare. The court heard that after taking his son home, David returned to the hotel to collect his wife and his son’s girlfriend, at which point he thanked the staff, apologized, and shook hands with the injured party.
The Ferrycarrig Hotel, a four-star property on the banks of the River Slaney in County Wexford, is part of the Griffin Group, a hospitality company with roots dating back to the 1920s. The hotel operates 102 bedrooms, all overlooking the estuary, and features the Reeds Restaurant, which has held two AA rosettes for seven consecutive years.
Judge Cheatle stated he was satisfied that the security team acted appropriately given genuine concerns for the young man’s safety, and that David had indeed used threatening language on the night. However, the judge credited David for apologizing to the injured party at the hotel.
Noting David’s 17 previous convictions—which included a six-month suspended sentence for assault issued by Wexford Circuit Criminal Court earlier this year following a District Court appeal, alongside traffic and public order offenses dating back to 2010—Judge Cheatle imposed a €200 fine with six months allowed for payment.