A Greenwood County jury sentenced William Bryan Morgan to 30 years in prison Wednesday for the June 2021 shooting death of his stepson, Caleb Donnelly, a case prosecutors said turned on Morgan’s decision to arm himself and pursue the 29-year-old rather than wait for law enforcement.
The verdict came after a trial in the Eighth Circuit, where Solicitor David Stumbo argued Morgan “hunted down and killed a family member simply because he had grown weary of dealing with the symptoms of Caleb’s mental illness.” A judge imposed the sentence with no possibility of parole, according to a news release from the solicitor’s office.
Deputies had been called twice to the property on the night of the killing. The first response followed a dispute at a party; officers took Donnelly to the small outbuilding behind Morgan’s house where he lived.
When deputies returned after reports Donnelly had damaged the main residence, they told Donnelly’s mother they had enough evidence to secure an arrest warrant but suggested he could be held for the weekend while the family sought mental‑health help, the release states.
During that conversation, Morgan retrieved a .357 Magnum revolver and “went looking” for Donnelly, prosecutors said. Donnelly’s body was later found in the outbuilding. Morgan was arrested two days later after emerging from woods near the home.
Greenwood County, where the shooting occurred, sits in South Carolina’s Piedmont and had a population of 69,351 in the 2020 census. The county was created in 1897 from parts of Abbeville and Edgefield counties, which had once formed the old Ninety-Six District — a name traders gave the area after noting six creeks running south from the Saluda River and nine from the Savannah.
The first cotton mill opened in the town of Greenwood in 1890, and the arrival of the Charlotte and South Carolina Railroad in 1852 had earlier linked the region’s cotton economy to wider markets.
“Caleb deserved compassion, not bloodshed and death, from family that he trusted. Our office will continue to stand up for vulnerable victims and hold those who harm them accountable.”
David Stumbo, Eighth Circuit Solicitor
Morgan admitted to investigators that he shot Donnelly several times and fired a final round to put him “out of his misery,” according to the solicitor’s news release. South Carolina prison records show Morgan was transferred to a state facility on Nov. 19.