“When I opened the door, it was like aggression automatically,” Ebony Watson told 9News, recalling the March 3 encounter that ended with her handcuffed in a patrol car for 22 minutes while her 8-year-old son screamed inside their apartment.
Watson filed suit Friday in Denver County District Court against three Denver Police Department officers, alleging wrongful arrest, excessive force and racial discrimination over a $54 laptop package that turned out never to have been missing.
The lawsuit, first reported by 9News and obtained by PEOPLE, says officers relied entirely on a leasing agent’s faulty identification and a surveillance video showing a woman with long, red dreadlocks — a description that matched nothing about Watson.
“These officers knew they had the wrong suspect,” Watson’s attorney, Benjamin DeGolia, said in a statement shared with PEOPLE. “Ms. Watson looks nothing like the woman they suspected of stealing packages, who had long, red dreadlocks in the surveillance video. Instead of performing even basic investigative tasks, they decided it was easier to just detain the first Black woman they came into contact with.”

Body-camera footage reviewed by 9News shows two of the three officers stepping around the corner from Watson’s front door to re-watch the video on a phone, muting their body-cam microphones while they did so. When Watson asked to see the footage, one officer refused, telling her it would be used as “evidence in court.” Minutes later, officers handcuffed her and placed her in the back of a patrol vehicle.
Only after Watson was already detained did two officers return to the leasing office, where the manager checked the key-fob log and identified a different resident — also named Ebony — as the person in the video.
“No wonder she’s crying,” one officer can be heard saying on body-cam audio captured by 9News. The officers then returned to the patrol car and released Watson, telling her they “were provided information from leasing that was obviously bad information.”
“Without a doubt, they’re going to point the finger at the property management company here and say they gave us bad information. But the police have to investigate. That’s why they are the police. That’s their core job.”
— Benjamin DeGolia, Watson’s attorney, speaking to 9News
The next day, the apartment manager called police to report that a full audit of the mailroom had located the package — it had been there the whole time. According to the lawsuit, Watson suffered a panic attack in the patrol car, vomited out the window, and has since required new medication and ongoing treatment for anxiety, hypervigilance and a fear of police.
DeGolia told 9News that basic due diligence — checking the mailroom, reviewing key-fob records for Watson’s unit, comparing the suspect’s description to the person at the door — would have revealed both that no crime occurred and that they had the wrong person. The lawsuit frames the failure as a violation of the equal-protection clause of the Colorado Constitution.

“I just need people to understand the effect that it had on my life,” Watson told 9News. “It changed me so much. You can’t do that to people, treat people wrong, and think that it’s okay.”
The Denver Police Department did not immediately respond to requests for comment from PEOPLE on Saturday. A department review of the officers’ actions remains ongoing, DPD told 9News.