The New York Yankees are hunting a catcher after Ryan Jeffers accepted Minnesota’s qualifying offer, and the most intriguing name on the board might be a $73 million All-Star the Atlanta Braves are trying to move.
Sean Murphy’s value has cratered — he played just 33 games in 2026 and hasn’t topped 100 since his All-Star 2023 — but the Braves have a cheaper, younger alternative in Drake Baldwin, and MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand said that makes the 32-year-old expendable.
Heavy.com detailed a hypothetical framework: the Yankees would send right-hander Chien-Fan Lai and infielder Jackson Lovich to Atlanta for Murphy, with the Braves eating the final two years of the six-year deal.
Atlanta’s motivation is straightforward. Baldwin’s ascent to an All-Star level has created a logjam behind the plate, and the front office would rather redirect Murphy’s salary toward other roster needs. “Drake Baldwin’s ascent to an All-Star level has left the Braves with a surplus behind the plate, making the 32-year-old Murphy expendable for Atlanta,” Feinsand told MLB.com.
“Although Murphy has battled injuries and offensive inconsistency over the past few years — he was limited to only 33 games in 2026 — his strong arm and pitch-calling skills could make him appealing to a club in need of catching help.”

New York’s need is just as clear. Austin Wells showed promise in 2026, but the Yankees have lacked a proven, right-handed complement. Murphy’s career 6.14 games-per-home-run rate with Atlanta — 50 homers in 307 games — fits the short porch in the Bronx, and his 2025 season (16 homers, 2.5 bWAR in 94 games) remains the most recent evidence of his ceiling.
The risk is durability. Murphy has not stayed healthy for a full season since 2023, and catchers with injury histories rarely age gracefully into their mid-30s. If the Braves absorb the back-end money, the prospect cost (Lai and Lovich) represents a modest outlay for a potential bounce-back, but the Yankees would still carry the 2027 and 2028 luxury-tax hits unless Atlanta subsidizes further.

Heavy.com noted the deal only makes sense “if the price isn’t high (which there’s no way it would be).” That calculus shifts if another club — the Rangers, the Giants — decides Murphy’s defensive reputation justifies a bigger prospect package.
The hot stove is warming up ahead of a potential lockout, and Feinsand’s reporting suggests Atlanta is motivated to move quickly.
The Yankees have the prospect depth to satisfy the Braves without touching their top tier, but they also have internal options (Ben Rice, J.C. Escarra) if the medical reviews on Murphy’s knee and shoulder raise red flags. The next formal checkpoint is the General Managers meetings in early November, where trade frameworks typically crystallize.