“You’re Not Limited to What You Think You Know How to Play,” Justin Told the Acoustic Shoppe

“You’re not limited to what you think you know how to play,” Justin told The Acoustic Shoppe, describing the moment open E tuning on the Deering Julia Belle rewired his muscle memory.

Deering built the five-string resonator banjo with Alison Brown from John Hartford’s own drawings, and the instrument arrived in the shop as a production model that carries a genuine Hartford lineage.

The Julia Belle is a tribute banjo that refuses to be a novelty. Hartford’s original Deering had no tone ring, a choice that gave his sound a distinct, woody character.

The Julia Belle keeps the spirit but adds Deering’s -06- 20-hole bell bronze tone ring on a three-ply violin-grade maple rim — the same ring found in Deering’s standard bluegrass models — giving the open E voice more crispness and projection without sacrificing warmth. “A little more crisp and clarity, but still woody,” is how the shop described the result.

Hartford’s Art Becomes Inlay

The visual identity comes straight from Hartford’s sketchbook. Alison Brown, a longtime friend of the Hartford family and owner of John’s prototype Deering low banjo, pored over his personal collection of drawings with the family’s permission. She selected a paddle wheel, a riverboat, and a sketch of Captain Trone — the pilot who taught Hartford to run the paddlewheeler on the Julia Belle Swain — for the fingerboard inlays in pearloid.

The enigmatic faceless woman in a flowing dress from Hartford’s art became the peghead inlay, copper hair and blue dress rendered in metal, and the banjo took her name: Julia Belle. At the 22nd fret, the name appears in Hartford’s own handwriting. Alison Brown’s signature inlay sits on the back of the peghead, her mark on the project.

Shop Review: Deering Julia Belle Banjo Carries Hartford Lineage, Open-E Tuning Rewires Muscle Memory
Photo: acousticvibesmusic.com

“I love my banjos to sound as warm and full as possible. I think that tone tends to draw people in, particularly folks who are not that familiar with the banjo or are put off by the traditional bright, poppy bluegrass banjo sound.”

Alison Brown told Acoustic Vibes Music, explaining her preference for the thicker Evans head design that recreates the fat tones of the original 5 Star heads and the specific string gauges she specifies: .012, .014, .020w, .024w, .012.

Radius Board, Extended Range, and the Feel of Butter

The neck is quartersawn mahogany with a satin finish that players describe as frictionless. “It’s just like butter,” Justin said. The fingerboard is radiused AAA ebony, extended two frets past the standard 22 to 24 frets with an overhanging board that required Deering to curve the tension-hook spacing around the extension — a visual oddity the shop acknowledges but confirms is structurally sound.

The radiused 11/16-inch Deering Smile bridge follows the board’s curve so every string sits at the same height over the frets it plays.

Deering Banjos Julia Belle Unboxed Banjo Review — The Acoustic Shoppe

The radius divides opinion among banjo players. A flat board excels at clean two-to-three pull-offs; the radius makes thumb wraps effortless and seventh chords easier, favoring chord-based backup and up-the-neck shapes. Fifth-string spikes come installed, allowing quick capoing without a sliding capo in the way. Planetary tuners with black buttons, nickel hardware, and a tapered mahogany-stained resonator complete the build.

Weight, Availability, and the Alternatives on the Wall

This is a full tone-ring resonator banjo. The shop’s two most recent units weighed 11.5 and 12.1 pounds on the shipping scale, so a good strap is not optional. If weight is the deal-breaker, the White Lotus — a tone-ring-less Deering that still sounds like it has one — deserves a look.

The Julia Belle is a specialty voice; Greg Cahill of Special Consensus carries one for a couple of songs in his set because of the specific sound it makes.

The shop does not have a Julia Belle in stock today. The most recent listing was $5,999, and orders run through Deering with the shop’s 23-point professional inspection and Dread-Not Guarantee — a 30-day in-home trial and a full year to trade in for up to 90% of the pre-tax purchase price in credit, less round-trip shipping.

For players who want a pro Deering resonator banjo this week, two alternatives are on the wall: the Tenbrooks Saratoga Star at $6,549 (maple neck, high gloss, -06- bronze ring, Greg Deering’s inlay pattern) and the Eagle II at $3,358 (Twenty-Ten ring, slender D neck, 1-1/4-inch nut, high gloss).

Model Price (USD) Tone Ring Neck / Board Finish Status
Deering Julia Belle $5,999 (last listed) -06- bell bronze Quartersawn mahogany, radiused ebony Satin Order through shop
Tenbrooks Saratoga Star #0558 $6,549 -06- bronze Quartersawn curly maple, AAA ebony High gloss, Tenbrooks Red In stock
Eagle II #2327 $3,358 Twenty-Ten Quartersawn maple, slender D, 1-1/4″ nut High gloss, Eagle Red In stock

Who This Banjo Is For

“If you’re a Hartford fan, this is kind of a cool banjo for you,” John at the shop said. It suits the player who wants to break out of open G habits — open E and the radius board both push toward new ideas.

Look elsewhere if the priority is a traditional Scruggs voice for every song (the Saratoga Star), a lighter instrument (the White Lotus), or a first banjo. For that last category, Greg Cahill’s advice in the shop’s learn-to-play resources and the Deering Goodtime guide are the starting points; the Julia Belle waits for when open E starts calling.

Alison Brown, born in Hartford, Connecticut, in 1962, won the Canadian National Banjo Championship at twelve and became the first woman to receive the International Bluegrass Music Association’s Banjo Player of the Year award in 1991.

After graduating from Harvard University and earning an MBA from UCLA, she joined Alison Krauss’s Union Station for three years before co-founding Compass Records in 1995, which grew into an internationally recognized label for acoustic music. She won a Grammy Award in 2001 for “Leaving Cottondale” and received the IBMA Distinguished Achievement Award in 2015.

Ask the shop about ordering one; they check timing with Deering and keep the buyer posted until it ships.