Federal judges on Monday pressed the Justice Department to explain why it opposes a court order requiring ICE to follow its own rules on warrantless arrests in Colorado, with one jurist bluntly asking why agents aren’t wearing body cameras to prove they’re doing the job right.
The three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit heard arguments in Ramirez Ovando v. Mullin, a class action filed by the ACLU of Colorado on behalf of four immigrants detained for 15 to 100 days last year.
None were targets of the operations that swept them up; each was a “collateral” arrest made without a warrant and, the plaintiffs argue, without the legally required finding that they were likely to flee before a warrant could be obtained.
“We should have facts. We should know what’s going on,” said Judge Harris L. Hartz, a George W. Bush appointee, during oral arguments. “I was pretty sure there was a directive that ICE agents involved in arrests should have body cams. If there are body cams, we know what’s going on. If you really want to convince a court that you’re doing things right, use a body cam.”
DOJ attorney Daniel F. Mummolo argued that judges should not be “intruding on” ICE officers’ field assessments, warning that the injunction would chill enforcement “for fear of contempt proceedings.” Hartz wasn’t buying it. “I don’t see why that would chill any officer,” he said, adding that much of the order simply restates ICE’s stated policy.
District court identifies systemic pattern
Senior U.S. District Judge R. Brooke Jackson, a Barack Obama appointee, issued a preliminary injunction last November after a two-day hearing. He concluded the plaintiffs had shown their cases were “not isolated incidents, but part of a larger policy, pattern, or practice by ICE” of failing to ascertain flight risk before making warrantless arrests, Colorado Politics reported.
Testimony at that hearing included the assistant ICE field director in Denver misstating the legal standard for a warrantless arrest. The former head of Denver’s ICE office testified that if targets of operations “have people who are with them also illegally present, they will be arrested, as well” — a description that sounds more like a dragnet than a flight-risk assessment.
Compliance collapsed after the injunction
The problems didn’t stop with the order. In March, plaintiffs told Jackson that arrest forms produced under his order “universally fail to adhere” to the injunction. At a subsequent hearing, multiple ICE employees testified they had received no additional training, were unaware of the order, or still misunderstood the policy. In May, Jackson found the government had “materially violated” his prior order and directed immediate retraining of Colorado ICE staff.
That sequence — order, noncompliance, retraining order — is what brought the government to the 10th Circuit seeking to lift the injunction entirely.
Government relies solely on policy manual
At the appeals court, Mummolo leaned on ICE’s written policy, which mirrors the statutory standard, as proof of compliance. “There isn’t anything to suggest they’re not following the policy,” he insisted.
Judge Joel M. Carson III, a Donald Trump appointee, cut to the core of the dispute. “They came forward with evidence,” he said of the plaintiffs. “What evidence did the government come forward with to say they were wrong?”
Mummolo pointed again to the policy document. “I guess the answer to the question is you did not put on rebuttal evidence,” Carson replied. “You did not put on evidence that agents in the field were following the official department policy.”
Judge Richard E.N. Federico, a Joe Biden appointee, noted the lower court heard testimony from immigration officers “who were unable to articulate the legal standards of the statute or even what their arrest authority was.”
Standing questions loom over the class
The panel also pressed the plaintiffs’ attorney, Timothy MacDonald of the ACLU, on whether the named plaintiffs still have standing to seek injunctive relief given changed circumstances. Hartz warned that if the named plaintiffs aren’t likely to be arrested again without a warrant and without a flight-risk finding, they can’t represent a class seeking that relief.
MacDonald argued the case is “quite modest” — the government remains free to bring witnesses at the merits stage to show the plaintiffs’ evidence reflects only “idle talk.”
Federal law permits a warrantless immigration arrest only when officers have probable cause that a person is in the country illegally and “likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained.” The statute, 8 U.S.C. § 1357, makes the flight-risk finding a prerequisite, not an afterthought.
The plaintiffs’ core claim is straightforward: ICE in Colorado has been treating the flight-risk requirement as optional, arresting everyone encountered during targeted operations regardless of whether they pose a flight risk, then sorting it out later in detention.
What the panel’s split appointments signal
The questioning cut across ideological lines. Hartz (Bush), Federico (Biden), and Carson (Trump) all expressed skepticism of the government’s position — Hartz on the lack of transparency, Federico on the officers’ inability to state the law, Carson on the absence of rebuttal evidence. That alignment suggests the panel sees this as a question of judicial oversight and evidentiary burden, not immigration policy preference.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit, which heard Monday’s arguments in Denver, covers six states across 560,625 square miles — roughly one-seventh of the nation’s land mass. Congress created the circuit in 1929 after the Eighth Circuit had grown to encompass 13 states, making it the largest in the country; Chief Justice William Howard Taft backed the split to ease the crushing caseload.
The court did not indicate when it will rule. The injunction remains in place while the appeal is pending.